Feb. 7, 2026

Whoosh! That Really Was a Week in Tech: Winner-Take-All AI and the $1 Trillion Selloff

Whoosh! That Really Was a Week in Tech: Winner-Take-All AI and the $1 Trillion Selloff
Keen On America
Whoosh! That Really Was a Week in Tech: Winner-Take-All AI and the $1 Trillion Selloff

"I didn't use my own software this week because the OpenAI agents were better. And that's me retiring my own software." — Keith Teare

Something broke this week. Both Anthropic and OpenAI launched multi-agent systems—"agent swarms"—that don't just assist with tasks but replace custom-built software entirely. The market noticed: Adobe, Salesforce, Workday, and other legacy SaaS companies saw their stocks collapse in what some are calling a trillion-dollar selloff. Keith Teare joins Andrew Keen on Super Bowl weekend to unpack what may be the most consequential week in AI since ChatGPT launched.

The conversation ranges from the Anthropic-OpenAI advertising spat (Dario Amodei's Super Bowl ad vs. Sam Altman's "online tantrum") to the deeper structural shifts: Microsoft and Amazon becoming utilities, Google betting $185 billion on an AI-first pivot, and Elon Musk merging SpaceX with xAI to put data centers in space. Along the way, Teare and Keen debate whether the AI race is a myth or a wacky race, whether venture capital is in crisis, and what happens to human labor when agents do the work.


About the Guest

Keith Teare is a British-American entrepreneur, investor, and technology analyst. He co-founded RealNames Corporation, a pioneering internet company, and later served as Executive Chairman of TechCrunch. He is the founder of That Was The Week and SignalRank, and publishes a widely-read weekly newsletter on technology, venture capital, and the business of innovation. He brings four decades of experience in Silicon Valley to his analysis of the AI revolution.


Chapters:
00:00 Super Bowl and the Anthropic ad
The spat between Dario Amodei and Sam Altman

01:09 "Fundamentally dishonest"
Keith's take on the ad war and who's really Dick Dastardly

05:47 Anthropic's breakout week
Claude Opus 4.6 and the agent swarm launch

06:48 OpenAI Codex
Multiple agents collaborating on tasks in 10-15 minutes

07:42 "It replaces software"
Keith retires his own custom-built tools

08:16 The trillion-dollar selloff
Adobe, Salesforce, Workday, PayPal collapse

11:02 Infrastructure vs. innovation
Microsoft and Amazon become "utilities"

11:45 Google's $185 billion bet
Pivoting from hybrid to AI-first

13:15 The SpaceX/xAI merger
Musk's plan for space-based data centers

15:18 The AI wacky race
Kimi, OpenAI, Anthropic leapfrog Google

17:03 Does AI make us smarter?
Leverage tools, not intelligence

18:53 AI growing up, CEOs not
The adolescence of the industry

21:06 US job openings hit five-year low
The coming labor crisis

22:44 The VC crisis
Five funds sucking the air out of the room

25:04 Palantir and Anduril
The winners in defense AI

25:42 Facebook as laggard
Huge revenues, no AI momentum

26:41 The Washington Post crisis
"Boogeyman journalism" and partisan media

29:23 Ads in AI
Paid links vs. enshittification

31:26 Spotify's innovation
Physical book + audiobook bundle

32:32 Startup of the week
Cursor for CRM, $20M from Sequoia

33:45 Om Malik on the end of software distribution
From CDs to app stores to self-made

35:41 Super Bowl prediction
Seattle vs. New England

36:02 Closing
"That really was the week in tech"


Links & References

Mentioned in this episode:

That Was The Week newsletter by Keith Teare

Anthropic's Super Bowl ad and ad-free pledge (CNBC)

Sam Altman's response to Anthropic ads (TechCrunch)

SpaceX acquires xAI in $1.25 trillion merger (CNBC)

The Washington Post layoffs and crisis (Poynter)

Om Malik on the evolution of software distribution

OpenAI Codex app launch (OpenAI)

About Keen On America
Nobody asks more impertinent questions than the Anglo-American writer, filmmaker and Silicon
Valley entrepreneur Andrew Keen. In Keen On America , Andrew brings his sharp Transatlantic
wit to the forces reshaping the United States — hosting daily interviews with leading thinkers
and writers about American history, politics, technology, culture, and business. With nearly
2,800 episodes since the show launched on TechCrunch in 2010, Keen On America is the most
prolific intellectual interview show in the history of podcasting.
Website | Substack | YouTube

00:00 - Super Bowl and the Anthropic ad

01:09 - "Fundamentally dishonest"

05:47 - Anthropic's breakout week

06:48 - OpenAI Codex

07:42 - "It replaces software"

08:16 - The trillion-dollar selloff

11:02 - Infrastructure vs. innovation

11:45 - Google's $185 billion bet

13:15 - The SpaceX/xAI merger

15:18 - The AI wacky race

17:03 - Does AI make us smarter?

18:53 - AI growing up, CEOs not

21:06 - US job openings hit five-year low

22:44 - The VC crisis

25:04 - Palantir and Anduril

25:42 - Facebook as laggard

26:41 - The Washington Post crisis

29:23 - Ads in AI

31:26 - Spotify's innovation

32:32 - Startup of the week

33:45 - Om Malik on the end of software distribution

35:41 - Super Bowl prediction

36:02 - Closing

0:00 Hello, my name is Andrew Keen. Welcome to Keen on America, the daily show about everything that matters with the world's leading commentators and thinkers. Hello everybody. It is Saturday the 7th of February. I am talking to, as always, from San Francisco. Tomorrow is the Super Bowl, the annual American.

0:41 Celebration of all things football. Um, one piece in the Financial Times talks about how the NFL became America's true national pastime. It's the one thing that brings Americans together, and of course it's taking place tomorrow in Silicon Valley and the heart of San Jose. But as it happens, uh, the. Super Bowl is not bringing Silicon Valley together. In fact, it's dividing them. That's been the big story of the week out here. Anthropic have a big ad about the absence of advertising in their product, and Sam Altman has lashed out. Keith, I know you are a keen observer of all things ChatGPT and Anthropic.

1:26 What should we make of this latest, um, spat between Altman and Anthropic; Dario Amodei well, the, the, the joke on the streets here is, um, of course Anthropic doesn't have ads. Because it doesn't have consumers. Um, and so ads would play no role for it. Whereas OpenAI has hundreds of millions of consumers, many of whom use the service for free. So ads make sense, but the, the more serious point underneath that, um, pushback is to do with the content of Amodei's ads are basically fundamentally dishonest.

2:09 Uh, and deceitful. Uh, he's making the point that OpenAI plans to have the AI tell you different things based on what it's trying to sell you, which is just not true. Um, and, but it's, when was the last time Keith, you ever saw an honest ad? By definition, those are ads by definition at dishonest, so I don't know why we should object to that. Um, uh, uh, Altman had an interesting ex-post. Uh, he acknowledges that the philanthropic ad. Is funny and it made him laugh, but he says, and and it's interesting that the way he frames it, he suggests that most people can't afford anthropic. It's too expensive.

2:50 Only wealthy people use Anthropic and therefore the OpenAI. Advertising model is actually suited for less well off people. It's an old argument. It was made back in the Web 2.0. Age as well. Yeah. Look, I've, I, I've advocated for, um, not ads. I don't like the word ads 'cause it conjuress up exactly what, uh, Amodei is implying. Uh, but paid links, a paid, a paid link. Uh, if relevant to the context can be a helpful thing. And I, I see that more and more actually in places like Instagram where the ads are relevant to something I'm kind of interested in and I don't object to them as much.

3:32 So I think, I think there's a smart way for Altman to be right and I think for sure am day has done. It is a good marketing move by him, don't get me wrong, but it's. And you're right, ads are doula. Um, but it isn't like the Apple 1984 ad, which was. Truly symbolizing, um, a shift and a change in Apple's position in the world. Thi this is just, um, childish. I mean, it's like playground stuff, so it doesn't, it doesn't really, uh, you don't draw the conclusion that Anthropic is breaking through to a, to a new, oh, they're coming back. I hadn't thought of the, uh, the Apple 84 ad, but the anthro, uh, the Apple 84 ad was very much.

4:18 Directed against IBM and their model. So it was equally childish in the sense that they were bashing their rival. Yeah, it, it, it was childish, but. Luckily for Apple, it reinforced a true theme in the real world, whereas no one in the real world thinks that Anthropic is looking out for the interest of consumers, 'cause it isn't a consumer company. It's just, well, I use it. I'm a consumer. I'm not sure that's an entirely true. Um, Altman's been ridiculed, uh, according to the BBC, at least for what they call his online tantrum. Do you think it reached a nerve? Uh, Altman's usually a fairly smart, self-controlled guy. Why, why did he respond so angrily?

5:01 Well, it goes to the roots of his personality. I mean, Al Altman is, um, you know, a somewhat deceitful and devious person himself, probably more so than Amodei. And when you get under his skin, a bit like Trump. He reacts and, and, and that's what happened there. Um, you know, if you look at the other player, uh, Demis, uh, Hassabis um, of the three, he's the most, you know, uh, I'd say fundamentally, intellectually honest of the three. Well, it's interesting you put him in their company. He is, of course not the CEO of Google, although he runs.

5:44 DeepMind, he's the Google AI chief. I wonder, Keith, whether one could argue that. Altman was already irritated enough this week. Anthropic's had a remarkable week, uh, a breakout moment according to the FT with the launch of, um, their new, uh, version of, uh, of, of Claude, which has really riled the markets. How big a week has it been, do you think, for Anthropic? And do you think that's the real reason why Altman has lashed out? Well, look, j just to frame it, uh, I think the answer to that is no. Because literally the day after that, anthropic Launch ChatGPT launched version 5.3 of of its, um, modeled, which was a very similar leap.

6:36 The Anthropic one, and indeed yesterday I spent most of yesterday playing with both of them, and I'm an anthropic user, as you know. We talked about, are you a consumer? Keith? Never. Nevermind whether I'm a consumer, but I am now a convert to OpenAI. I used OpenAI to do the You But you've always been a convert. No, I've used Anthropic forever. I don't, I don't use OpenAI um, uh, because I see it as a consumer app. I'm, uh, and I'm using it for real use cases in my work. But yesterday I switched to OpenAI because the, the new is called, uh, OpenAI Codex, which is an app that runs on the Mac. Uh, not to be confused with the codex they've had for months. And it is, it is, um, it and Anthropic, and this is both of them.

7:21 Uh, so this is the big story. Both of them have introduced, um, the ability for the interface, the chat interface to launch multiple workers, if you will, or agents in their language. So if you give it a task that has multiple skills. It will spin up an agent for each of those skills and they'll collaborate with each other. In the case of Anthropic, they literally talk to each other. In the case of OpenAI, there's a, a, a kind of a boss agent that each of the other agents talk to one-on-one, but they're all collaborating on your job and the outcome of the job. And it can take, you know, anywhere for depending on the complexity of the job, anywhere between 10 and 15 minutes to complete.

8:06 And it replaces. Software. You know, you don't, you don't really use software anymore. You use Yeah, I mean, that's the headline. Keith, say it again? It replaces software. I mean, that's a massive statement. You've been hinting at this now for months, but it, this seems to be the week where the promise of replacing software has become a reality with the launch of Claude Opus 4.6 and of course the new ChatGPT, uh, a lot of the headlines this week have been about. And, and this one is about Anthropic Anthropic triggering a a trillion dollar sell off. When we talk about replacing software, it means that software companies are in suddenly being dramatically hit on the markets and, and in every other sense.

8:55 Yeah. I mean, if we define software as. Take my Creator automation.ai, which I built for myself with AI. I didn't use it this week because the OpenAI agents were better than my software, and, and that's me grandfathering my own software, or that's the wrong word, isn't it? Retiring my own software, which was custom built for my use case, and OpenAI now does a better job than my software, and by the way, saves me about two hours. That otherwise I would've had to use the other. The other one is Claude Bart, which has now been renamed to Open Claw. Yeah.

9:35 You've got, uh, you, you quote in your post of the week, um, om who says Open Claw is ht, HAWT. Well, and OOII, I put it to work on my newsletter as well. Two, I, I actually produced two copies of my newsletter. One with OpenAI, uh, and one with Openclaw and, uh, actually a third one with Claude and Claude didn't, wasn't very good. Um, for my use case, it's probably good. Uh, other things, it's very good in Excel, for example, if you use the Claude Plug into Excel, it's fantastic. Um, but, um, both Open Claw and OpenAI did a actually a really, really good job.

10:18 Now, the nice thing about Open Claw is, um, I can embed its persona in a telegram. Uh, uh, account and I can talk to it and ask it to do things from anywhere in the world, and it's running on my computer at home and will carry out my tasks. So when, when you put it all together this week was a massive shift in how you use AI and how productive it can be for you, right? And, and let's talk about the impact on the rest of the market. As I said, um. Some people believe that this latest version of Anthropic's Claude triggered a trillion dollar se sell off.

10:59 What will it mean to companies like. Adobe middle market companies look at the stock price. It's dramatically collapsed over the last few days, and, and they're not alone. The same has happened with PayPal and many other software companies. Yeah, Salesforce. Um, uh, yeah, and Salesforce used to be a cutting edge company. Now it appears more and more archaic. Workday, I noticed that Workday, um, all, all, all of these companies have had massive reductions in their share price. I mean, in a way, Google is lucky to be in the AI game. If it wasn't, it would've had a similar. Reduction based on workspaces and, and, and, um, you know, Google Docs and all that stuff. So, so ba basically what's happened is the stock market has moved away from software companies and SaaS companies as well.

11:49 It, it, it can't yet move towards AI companies because they're not listed yet. They, they probably, well, Google is. Google is, but actually Google had a bit of a drop this week as well. 'cause it's a hybrid. Um, and, uh, and you know, I don't believe it will stay a hybrid. I think it's gonna go the whole way and become an AI company. Uh, unlike saying Microsoft, which had a huge hit this week because it's deemed to not be an AI company. And, and Amazon, Amazon had a terrible week. I mean, just to put things in perspective, um, Google, Google's numbers came out this week. They beat. Expectations dramatically. And yet, uh, the stock declined even though they committed $185 billion this year to investment in AI.

12:33 So it does reflect the complete shift in, in the way the markets are viewing tech companies and their valuations. Yeah. Yeah. Although I, you know, I, I think we should say out loud. Google are doing the right thing by doing that and Oh, absolutely. And Amazon, I think, committed $200 billion and, and their, their, their stock, uh, lost about 10%. And, and Microsoft, of course, um, is increasingly looking of all these tech giants the least able to, uh, embrace AI, or at least as well, it, it's become a utility in the AI world, a bit like Oracle, Microsoft.

13:17 It, it isn't a player except at the infrastructure layer. And it, it will be able to charge a rent for that infrastructure through Azure as it does to OpenAI. But it, it isn't gonna be the company that transforms our experience. Right. And they're, they're cloud numbers. Uh, in, if not in crisis, certainly in decline, especially compared to to, to glue to Google's cloud numbers. So even on that front, they're not succeeding. The other thing to bring into this, 'cause I think it's part of it, is the merger between SpaceX and XAI. Yeah, I was gonna bring that up. I mean, Elon Musk as. Regular viewers, listeners to the show, knowing our conversations.

13:58 I'm not a big fan, but you have to admire, I mean, he thinks very clearly on this. And according to The Economist, he's betting his business empire on AI by merging XAI, uh, and SpaceX. So he's, he's part of this dramatic week, isn't he? Yeah. I mean, I think if you measure the effectiveness of the CEOs in, uh, or leaders in this space, he's the most definitive. You know, he says, this is what's gonna happen, here's what I'm gonna do. He then does it, and you know, in his case, he, it's, um, audacious. He wants to put apparently a million satellites into orbit, which are effectively data centers for AI processing, using the power of the sun to, to fuel 'em.

14:45 And, you know, there's no doubt even that's a huge audacious goal. He reckons by 36 months from now. Most of the power needed to run data centers and AI will be in space. Um, who we'll see. Yeah. Which is interesting because Google this week came out with more initiatives about their AI energy race, investing in earth bound energy. So that's gonna be an interesting story. Keith, a couple of months ago we did a show on AI. It seems every week we do a show on AI. We talked to, or you argued that the AI race is a myth and I. Argued that it's a bit of a wacky race every week there's a new leader.

15:27 Has anything changed this week in terms of the order? We have Google, we have Microsoft, we have OpenAI, we have Anthropic, we have XAI. Has anything dramatically changed or is it just that AI is moving ahead of the rest of the tech world? Uh, AI is moving ahead. Um. It's, we, it's easy to forget this, but the first player who stepped up to this new level of functionality was Kimi. K 2.5 is the version, which is a Chinese, uh, system that started this concept called agents swarms to, uh, put a swarm of agents against a task.

16:11 That was three weeks ago, I think. So the last three weeks have seen Kimmy. OpenAI and, and anthropic leapfrog Google actually. So Gemini now is a generation behind again and no doubt is already working on not being. So it is like the wacky race. It's every episode or every week it seems to be a new leader. One pulls ahead, one falls behind. Is there a dick dastardly here? Is it, I mean, for me, of course it's Musk. Uh, for others it's Altman some. It's Dario Amdis. It does it really depend on one's own perspective. I vaguely watched that show when I was a kid, but I can't, uh, I haven't got your ability to link it to what's going on, so, so I don't know who is Dick dastardly in this context.

16:58 The, the bad guy chasing down all everyone else and cheating is probably Amodei. If there is one, because he's, he's just using marketing and lying to try to look better when he, when he actually isn't any better. In other words, he's as bad as everybody else. Yeah. And the focus of your editorial this week is that the CEOs are not growing up, but does that reflect again, the reality of our AI age or however smart AI becomes and it's becoming smarter and smarter. It's not making humans any smarter. It doesn't make Elon Musk or Sam Aman or Dario Amodei, and we just accept that, that however smart AI becomes, we're always gonna be a bit dimwitted.

17:43 We're always gonna watch. Stick dastardly and wacky races. Yeah. I, I, I don't think exactly you of course, who, who, who was always mature. Were you, what were you doing when you, what were, you were watching? Six, uh, uh, when you were six Keith, uh, Shakespeare when I was six. You missed wacky races. How? I was six in 1960, so I think I was probably watching top of the pops. Uh, so you did have a little bit of triviality. You weren't always an adult or as much of an adult as you are now. I, I certainly wasn't, but, you know, but I, I, I, uh, I, we lost the thread there a little bit when you asked me that question. I was, I, I had it all teed up and now it's gone.

18:25 So. Okay. Well, let me tee you up again. Um. Are, are we dealing with these weirdly paradoxical realities that on the one hand, AI is becoming smarter and smarter and on the other hand we it's becoming dumber and dumber. Yeah. I've got it back. So, look, I I, I don't think we should be measuring AI's impact on whether it makes individual human smarter. Um, I, I, I think we, we are as smart as we are, we're all different. What it does is it makes us. Leverage tools to get more done, hopefully done better. Uh, not always true. Sometimes it gets done worse, hence the slop word.

19:06 Um, and it doesn't make us smarter. It just makes us better at using our smarts to get things done. And, and I think if it can achieve that, that's huge. But then why'd you write this editorial about AI growing up and the CEOs aren't? Well, so that is to do with two things. Uh, let's take AI growing up. This, this leapfrog from a single chat interface with a single AI to AI that can carry out work using multiple AI agents that it manages is, is a huge change in what AI can do and how fast it can do it, and how well it can do it. That's the AI growing up bit, the CEO's not growing up, is the mud fight between Altman and Amodei.

19:53 Um, basically when Amodei talks about adolescence in, in terms of the tech, it's ironic 'cause he's displaying adolescence in his use of advertising. And Altman is equally in his response showing adolescence when all of them have got better things to be doing, they, they're actually contributing massively. But having this side fight as they do it, that that's the CEO's not growing up bit. But, so what does that tell us that, are you optimistic that these people can become a little bit more mature or is that just the nature of things? They totally can. Yeah. I mean, I, all of every entrepreneur, and I'll include myself in this, in the, you know, in their learning phase.

20:38 When they, having their ass handed to them in all kinds of ways, uh, react, um, based on their past experience, you know, either better or worse. I, I had some when I was doing real names, roughly at their age. Uh, I remember thinking I could beat Microsoft in a fight. And I, I really thought I could. Um, and I didn't. I lost and had my ass handed to me. And over time you learn that not everything is under your control. And that is a maturing learning curve. They'll, they'll all get there, um, because the world won't be kind to them unless they go there. Well, one thing for sure is they've all got jobs and it was an, an interesting, another interesting.

21:23 Piece of this week's news, there's so many interesting stories this week, is that US job openings dropped to a five year low, uh, in December, 2025. More and more pessimism on the job front. One big piece, at least of media news was that the Washington Post. Uh, essentially committed suicide, at least according to the Atlantic. Is this an important week in terms, again, you've talked about swarms and bots and smart ais. Is this an important week or will it be seen Keith as an important week when it comes to what more and more people are believing to be a crisis of human labor?

22:05 I think it is the starting point of that. Uh, and most of these things are overreactions, uh, based on a misunderstanding of timing. I don't, I don't think timing suggests that. You know, anytime soon, meaning the next few months, you're gonna see a huge change in the job market. Um, I, you know, so I think the answer is there's always an emotionally overreaction and the stock market is the extreme of that. 'cause it reprices things very early once it sees a trend. So there is truth in the reactions, but timing wise, probably an overreaction.

22:46 Coming back to my favorite television program, wacky Races. It is made up of all sorts of interesting teams. Uh, and in terms of the AI wacky races, I mean, obviously we think of Anthropic and OpenAI and Google, Microsoft, Amazon XAI, but I know for you it's a more complicated race. The VCs are also participating, and in this week's editorial you imply that. They're not doing very well, but they're certainly not leading the pack when it comes to the AI race and this crisis of software. Can we talk, Keith, also maybe last week about the crisis of traditional venture capital as well?

23:29 Well, the, the crisis is, uh, what you could think of as. Um, a, a massive concentration of capital into a small number of hands. In venture capital, most of the money being raised and deployed is coming through about five funds. Um, those five funds, uh, sucking the air out of the room. So the, the, the venture ecosystem thrives due to seed investors. Who find these companies before anyone even knows they exist, and the seed investors are being starved of oxygen and many are threatened. With being viable.

24:10 And there's a lot of writing this week about that. Uh, three, three very good pieces. One from Beza Clarks and one from Dan Gray. And, um, I'm blanking on who the third one is. Um, and, and they all, uh, naval gazing about the impact of this structural shift in capital. For innovation. And I think that's, that's a reasonable concern. I do, I I do think that, um, really, really good angels and seed investors will still thrive. But, um, anyone in the middle is, is threatened. Yeah. And it, it, this is part of this crisis.

24:50 It's the middle market companies like Adobe is in crisis. Um, it's the five or six. AI companies that are dominating everything, whether they're private, privately owned or publicly owned. There'd probably be two IPOs, anthropic and OpenAI this year. So what's happening with Venture is a mirror and a cause, or perhaps a cause and a consequence of what's happening more broadly in tech. Is that fair? I mean, it's a, it's a winner take all economy in every sense. Yeah. Whether you are an investor, whether you are a developer, whether. Um, whether you are an ex, uh, you are an AI company Yeah.

25:32 And there's some public companies in there as well. And Palantir's results this week were spectacular. Um, it did actually suffer, um, a, a big rise and then a big drop in it. Share price. Over two days. Um, you think of and Unreal, who's the AI in? Yeah. And these are smart defense. Yeah. Smart military software companies. So the, the, the, you know, the s and p 510 years from now is not going to look anything like it does today. And if you're an investor, you want to be putting money into the future s and p 500, not the current one. One company we haven't mentioned actually is, is, is Facebook, are they a loser in this?

26:15 Are they They are. Are they a foot? No. Now in, in, in, in, uh, in the wacky racist, do they even have a team in this? Well, look, they're a fantastic company. They're revenues announced last week were huge, but their stock price has not gone up because in the AI race, Theran also ran. Trying to figure it out. They, they have a brand new team in place, building brand new platform to replace, uh, the LAMA platform that they've had for the last few years. There's a big internal debate about open source versus closed source models, but with the amount of money they've got, and, you know, time is on their side, they'll probably figure it out.

27:00 I don't think they'll, I think they'll be a survivor, but they're a laggard right now. Um, you sidestep the Washington Post question. Are you concerned that America no longer really has, it seems a, uh, a viable newspaper in its capital, especially in its rather precarious political state in, uh, in February, 2026? You know, I, I, I think the Washington Post has been challenged for, at, at least 10 years since, um, Kathy Graham. Um, moved on from it. I think, I think it's, it's challenge for a few reasons, but the first is it tied, its mast.

27:44 To the Biden administration and ended up taken the wrong side of most discussions and became irrelevant in a similar way to the New York Times by, by abandoning the, you know, the, the, um, being the source of truth and becoming a co, uh, a combatant, if you will, in the political wars. And, and so I think America lost. A news business, um, CNN tried to survive by being independent, uh, against M-S-N-B-C and Fox. But I think across the entire traditional media, you've had this partisan bifurcation of media and they're all gonna be losers because of it.

28:27 'cause most normal people want to make their own opinion from good journalism, and that hasn't been available. But there's less and less journalism. I mean, that, isn't that the point of the crisis at the Post? Is there, and I mean, whether you like normal or not, they're capable of, of high quality journalism. It's, it, it's um, I call it boogieman journalism. It's like. Every couple of weeks. There's a new boogieman this week. Is Jeffrey Epstein that distract? Well, he might legitimate. I mean, there, there are certain legitimate boogieman and, uh, Jeffrey Epstein seems to be one that, well, he, of course he is one, but for the entire media to get distracted from big issues by focusing only on this boogeyman and trying to un undermine, uh, Trump, only because of his.

29:19 Possible associations, or likely associations means that the entire narrative driven by the media's desire to sell clicks or, or papers or news or TV channels gets distracted. You know, before it was Russia interfering the election as the boogeyman. There's always a boogeyman. It's always about the media driving attention, and none of it is about what's really going on, which is so frustrating. What you call this attention economy is an advertising economy. And does that mean that maybe Dario Amid dies onto something by suggesting that when you insert ads into AI, you're only compounding attention and trivialization on all the other things that have gone wrong?

30:06 I'm, you know, I'm definitely against. What we would think of as ads in AI. Um, for, for, so you're in Amides Camp for good reason, even if you don't like it. Uh, well, no, no, no. Because I do know that OpenAI has also said it's against that, and that it has no intention of putting what we all think of as ads in AI. But it is thinking of working with, um, you know, if you think about the world, the digital world, everything that there is available to sell, read. Buy has a link. And so we live in a place where in order to have your ideas, products.

30:48 Services surfaced in any conversation with AI. It has to take the form of a link. And, you know, Amodei has links, uh, perplexity has links open, AI has links, and now they're saying, you know, you can pay us to put your link there in our free service if and only if it's relevant. To what the user is looking for. I think that's okay. I don't, I don't, but that's not the, in to, to borrow a word from Corey Doc, that's not the ification of AI or the beginnings of its ification. I, I, I, I don't think there's any intent.

31:28 And, and it would be counter to OpenAI's economic future. There is no intent to interfere with the AI itself and what it says does thinks, um, at all. So that's where the Amida ad is. Just, you know, uh, leveraging a, a nuance to try to depict something that isn't gonna happen. Well, there is other news outside AI. My tech company of the week is Spotify. I'm not always my favorite company. But then news this week was that when you buy a physical book now and they've done a deal with bookstore, um, you'll also get the audio book. It's always been one of my.

32:10 Irritations that you, on Amazon, at least an audible, if you buy the the audio book, you still have to buy the physical book. So that's still innovation. Keith, I don't know whether you are a, a reader of physical books or a listener to audio books, but this is good news. Spotify is still innovating. Yeah. If you look at this behind my head, it's books and there's a whole wall of them to my right here. So I do read physical books. Um, I, you know, that is innovation, but with a. Small. I, I would say, um, and it, it's smart as well. It's smart because I think the consumer will much prefer getting both in a single purchase. So I think I, I do think that's smart.

32:53 Um, but in the name of democracy, I gotta be fair and give you the last word with your startup of the week. This is a startup that raised $20 million from Sequoia to build the. Cursor of CRM sounds rather boring. Tell me about this company. Well, we all know that. Uh, what CRM is? Customer relationship management. Probably not Everyone knows what Cursor is. Cursor is, um, a, a rapper, um, uh, not, not a singer, um, a rapper as in paper, uh, around a rapper with a w around, um, using AI to write code. Um, or perform other tasks.

33:35 And, um, this, this is an AI wrapper around your customer list and your prospects list. Um, I dunno if it's any good, but the investors, what's it called? The investors who invested in it, certainly think, what's its name? The, the name of the company? Yeah. Didn't you say the name of the company already? No. It's your start of the week. It's your company, not mine. Start of the week is, um. Up. I think it's, uh, upstart, I think it's called. Oh, wow. That's so interesting. We're not quite sure of their name, but they are at least RA rapper, the cursor. They're, but I will say, uh, before we go, Andrew, that I think the poster of the week is the most illustrative.

34:21 It's from O Malick and Om, you know, you know, when we talk about music, we talk about music distribution, going from the radio. To vi and vinyl to cassettes, then to CDs, and then to streaming, and then back to vinyl. And what, what Omar's done is applied that same evolutionary scale, if you will, to software. And in his piece, he talks about, you know, the different eras of software, uh, distribution from, I remember when I started Easy Net, we put a cd. Cell a tape to the cover of the internet magazine and we also gave the CD to Compact to put in the box when he bought a laptop.

35:06 And software distribution was really hard. Then Mobile came along and suddenly there were two app stores and you could ship software to the whole world in five minutes. And, and, and it took the form of, uh, app stores and then there was sas. Which is the cloud version of software for enterprises, mainly through subscriptions or buying enterprise software. And what OM is pointing out is that software is now gonna be built by users for their own purposes. And it, it'll be self-made, uh, and I think it is pieces very thoughtful and really good. Yeah, software then becomes free in every sense, metaphorical, perhaps, and otherwise, although someone's gonna profit from it.

35:50 Uh, one other sector that's getting a lot of attention in the the Super Bowl week is the prediction market. The way in which, uh. Betting has become ubiquitous. Maybe we can talk about that another week. But let's add where we began, Keith, with the Super Bowl, not far from you in Palo Alto. In San Jose. Uh, who's gonna win between Seattle? Do you have any sense between Seattle and New England? I. Anyone who listens to my opinion about football is, um, is a beautiful, maybe Manchester United will win. They did win today. Andrew, against your team? Yeah. I, I am not really aware of that. Well, uh, this was the week that broke the software business. I hope next week it'll be equally dramatic.

36:32 Keith, uh, we, we need You, or, that was the weak newsletter. It keeps us up to date with a fascinatingly. Dramatic changing world. So, uh, we'll talk again next week. Thank you so much. You're welcome. Bye everyone.