The Summer the Internet Didn’t End: Oscar Schwartz on Why Australia’s Social Media Ban Failed

“Within the limited timeline that we have, there’s absolutely no question that it failed.” — Oscar Schwartz

Yesterday in DC, at the Family Online Safety Institute’s twentieth-anniversary conference, FOSI founder Stephen Balkam ended the event interviewing me about my take on regulating tech. Balkam is no fan of bans. When he came on the show in March, he told me that kids need more friction, not less technology. Still, social media prohibition was the talk of the Reagan Building. Australia’s eSafety Commissioner was there. Perhaps to hear a panel on social media regulation entitled “Beyond the Ban.”

Last December, on what its champions called Deactivation Day, Australia kicked all its under-16-year-olds off social media. Kids could go outside and play sports. Liberation Day. Instead, as Oscar Schwartz reports in this month’s Harper’s, about 85 percent of them are still online. All it took to evade the ban was a fake birth date. Or the digital image of an older sister.

It began, Schwartz tells me, when the premier of South Australia’s wife read Jonathan Haidt’s helicopter-parent screed The Anxious Generation. Two Murdoch campaigns later, it was law. The official charged with enforcing it never believed in it. And the kids at Melbourne’s Northcote High, whom Schwartz interviewed for the piece, saw the failure coming and doubled down on Snapchat and Instagram.

The summer the internet ended? More like proof that social media prohibition is as ill-advised as a completely unregulated market. Ban the ban. Or maybe ban the paranoid nonsense of Haidt and the Murdoch media.

ABOUT THE GUEST

Oscar Schwartz is a Melbourne-based writer whose long-form journalism has appeared in the New York Times, The Atlantic, Harper’s Magazine and The Monthly. He was previously a researcher at New York University. His poetry collection The Honeymoon Stage was shortlisted for the 2018 Queensland Literary Award for Poetry. His cover story for Harper’s is “Save the Children: The Making of Australia’s Social Media Ban.”

ABOUT KEEN ON AMERICA

Nobody asks more awkward questions than the Anglo-American writer and filmmaker Andrew Keen. With 3,000 episodes since the show launched on TechCrunch in 2010, Keen On America is a daily conversation about the ideas, books and arguments shaping the United States. New episodes every day.

LIVE IN SAN FRANCISCO: How to See America. Who Stole America’s Pride? Arlie Russell Hochschild in conversation with Andrew Keen, Manny’s, December 8. Tickets: https://www.eventbrite.com/e/how-to-see-america-who-stole-americas-pride-tickets-2003996604791

CHAPTERS

00:00 — Intro
00:31 — Harper’s and “The Summer the Internet Ended”
03:13 — eSafety, the bargaining code, and a premier’s wife reading Haidt
05:44 — The Anxious Generation as polemic
07:52 — A moral panic like jazz, MTV and comic books
10:47 — The Anglosphere and the 2012 decline
11:55 — Smartphones, and two Murdoch campaigns
15:32 — News Corp and Fitzy and Wippa
19:58 — Libertarians, The Wiggles, youth workers and researchers
25:31 — Albanese at the UN, plain packaging and island isolationism
28:03 — Robert French and the last sitting day
29:25 — YouTube, and putting the onus on the platforms
30:36 — Compliance, not a fight
32:56 — 85 percent still on
34:06 — Deactivation Day, fake birth dates and older siblings
35:55 — Julie Inman Grant never believed in it
38:02 — Wait and see, and the Digital Duty of Care
41:15 — What the kids at Northcote High think
43:28 — Social media as an amplifier, not a cause
46:17 — Get the mechanisms right
49:27 — New coalitions against big tech, and AI
51:11 — Closing