“Originalism is not the original way of thinking about the Constitution. The past can tell you some things, but it can’t answer our modern problems.” — Rachel Shelden
Before the midterms, Jacob Weisberg came on the show to identify eight cowards, including Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts, who have enabled the second Trump regime. His charge was that the Chief Justice had become too political. My guest today is no fan of Roberts. But she suggests that this political sin pales in comparison with Roberts’s sin of originalism.
Rachel Shelden is a historian at Penn State, and her new book, The Political Supreme Court, argues that the court was political by design for its first hundred years. Everybody knew it, she says. And that, in itself, wasn’t a problem.
It’s only recently, she reminds us, that we’ve invented the idea that the court is supreme. The justices had no grand courtroom until 1935, sitting in what everyone called the basement of the Capitol. And no robing room either, with justices dressing in front of other lawyers. They came to the bench from cabinets and governorships and Congress, they rode circuit and held jury trials in their own regions, and when they were done they wrote newspaper articles about their own constitutional views. None of this was thought improper, because the Constitution was understood as a political document that belonged to everybody, rather than a legal one that only belonged to the Supremes.
So where did the fiction of legal holiness come from? It began in the 1880s, Shelden says, with the professionalization of the law. It was marked by the founding of the American Bar Association and the establishment of professional law schools. Out of all this, America got the idea that the Supreme Court is the law above the law. That it should never be political.
Originalism arrived a century later to supply the scripture. Bork, Meese, Scalia, and now a bench of self-professed originalists claiming the authority of a founding generation that would have been horrified by a court this powerful and (dishonestly) political. A deep irony, Shelden calls it. The sin of originalism. Not particularly original, but very sinful.
ABOUT THE GUEST
Rachel A. Shelden is associate professor of history at Penn State and director of the George and Ann Richards Civil War Era Center. She took her doctorate at the University of Virginia and is the author of Washington Brotherhood: Politics, Social Life, and the Coming of the Civil War. She sits on the Historians Council on the Constitution at the Brennan Center and writes for Talking Points Memo. The Political Supreme Court: A Forgotten History is published by the University of North Carolina Press.
ABOUT KEEN ON AMERICA
Nobody asks more awkward questions than the Anglo-American writer and filmmaker Andrew Keen. With 3,000 episodes since the show launched on TechCrunch in 2010, Keen On America is a daily conversation about the ideas, books and arguments shaping the United States. New episodes every day.
CHAPTERS
00:00 — Intro
00:31 — AK: Weisberg, Roberts, and the assumption that justices are above politics
04:01 — The modern pipeline: law school, clerkship, federal bench
05:32 — They designed a political institution, and ran it as one
06:54 — AK: why has America fetishized the law?
09:17 — The courtroom was not built until 1935
09:50 — Pegs on the wall, and dressing in front of the lawyers
11:32 — A representative court: as many circuits as justices
12:30 — Riding circuit, and holding jury trials among your own people
14:37 — What the court did during the Civil War
17:41 — Congress regulated the court, and has since abdicated
18:02 — AK: historians are nostalgic. Are you?
21:42 — After Reconstruction, no friend to civil rights
24:17 — The myth of Marbury
26:30 — Hampton Carson, and a history commissioned for the 1890 centennial
28:26 — Bowie and Renan on judicial supremacy
29:20 — How progressives conceded the premise and argued inside it
30:24 — Court packing, and Laura Kalman’s revision
31:56 — Lincoln against the court after Dred Scott
34:02 — Original intent, original public meaning, and a fifty-year-old demand
36:00 — A court building its power on behalf of history
37:59 — AK: is Alito going? Are we over originalism?
41:36 — AK: the Dobbs leak, and the criminal inquiry
44:30 — Legitimacy came from interaction, and was traded for power
45:06 — Closing