“States seek power, but that doesn’t give you the license to do anything you want with your power.” — David M. Sacks
What is realism in international politics? It all depends whom you ask. And on this show, we’ve been asking a lot of people recently. For Charles Kupchan, it means a new Concert of Europe, with the great powers keeping order among themselves. For Jackson Lears, it means America giving up its empire. For Stephen Kinzer and John Mearsheimer, it means recognizing that America brought war to Ukraine. For Eliot Cohen, it’s all about learning to think like a strategist. Everyone, it seems, is a realist now. Especially the idealists.
Including, apparently, Mr. Realist himself, Donald Trump. “Too often,” he said in Shenzhen this week, “past leaders avoided talking to nations with whom they had disagreements.” With Xi Jinping on one side and his “good friend” Vladimir Putin on the other, the president announced, “Together, we are choosing a different course.” Xi supplied the unpalatable history lesson. When great powers are at peace, the world is secure. When they clash, the world is in chaos. Three great powers at one table. It sounded eerily like Kupchan’s Concert-of-Europe 2.0.
So what would Hans Morgenthau, the godfather of American realism, have made of it all? From a classically assimilated German-Jewish family, Morgenthau was spat on in his Coburg schoolyard in 1922 and watched Hitler’s thugs march through town while the police did nothing to stop the violence. Laws don’t matter, he concluded. Power does. And so when he came to the United States, Morgenthau founded the school of realism in international politics.
But in The Realist, the Council on Foreign Relations’ David M. Sacks (no, not that David Sacks) argues that we’ve misread him. Morgenthau’s understanding of power, Sacks explains, required both practical and ethical limits. He’d have seen Putin as a revolutionary power that no slice of Ukraine will satisfy. Above all, Sacks says, Morgenthau would have asked the question that none of the three leaders in Shenzhen are capable of answering ethically. What, exactly, is all this power for?
ABOUT THE GUEST
David M. Sacks is a senior fellow for Asia studies at the Council on Foreign Relations, where he works on US-China relations, Taiwan and security in the Indo-Pacific. He studied international relations at Carleton College and Johns Hopkins SAIS. The Realist: Hans Morgenthau and the Purpose of American Power is published by Henry Holt.
ABOUT KEEN ON AMERICA
Nobody asks more awkward questions than the Anglo-American writer and filmmaker Andrew Keen. With 3,000 episodes since the show launched on TechCrunch in 2010, Keen On America is a daily conversation about the ideas, books and arguments shaping the United States. New episodes every day.
LIVE IN SAN FRANCISCO: How to See America. Who Stole America’s Pride? Arlie Russell Hochschild in conversation with Andrew Keen, Manny’s, December 8. Tickets: https://www.eventbrite.com/e/how-to-see-america-who-stole-americas-pride-tickets-2003996604791
CHAPTERS
00:00 — Intro
00:31 — Hans Morgenthau, not that Morgenthau
03:26 — Politics Among Nations, and an eight-year biography
06:06 — What is a realist?
08:39 — Scientific Man vs. Power Politics, and power with limits
13:05 — Spat on in Coburg, 1922
14:33 — Hitler marches into town
16:42 — Bismarck, Weber and Nietzsche
19:22 — Meeting Carl Schmitt
23:15 — The Six-Day War and Zionism
24:28 — Kissinger’s seminar, and the Vietnam rift
27:30 — Diplomats, democracies and Wilson
29:49 — Hannah Arendt: a proposal and a love letter
32:18 — Writing in English, and Lincoln
35:18 — Against the Truman Doctrine
37:29 — Spheres in Europe, revolutions in Asia
39:57 — Mearsheimer, Ukraine and today’s realism
41:44 — America’s inheritance, and Carr’s mistake
44:28 — A frustrated idealist
46:16 — China, Taiwan and the balance of power
48:46 — Closing