John Doe Chinaman: Beth Lew-Williams on the History of Chinese Life under American Racial Law

“The systematic erasure of the Chinese was not an accident. It was, in many ways, structured.” — Beth Lew-Williams

Her Chinese-American grandfather asked her to turn off the tape recorder as they spoke. Beth Lew-Williams was a history student interviewing her grandad, her YeYe, two weeks before he died. He had come to America in 1930, aged nine, in violation of the Chinese Exclusion Acts, and was held on Angel Island for what he always said was nine months. Years later she looked up the file. It was “only” thirty-four days.

It was the shame of it all, he confessed to Lew-Williams, after she switched off the recorder. For his whole life, he blamed himself rather than American racial laws for his humiliation.

That student is now a professor of history at Princeton, and this year she has won more or less every prize for John Doe Chinaman, her history of Chinese life under American racial law. The Bancroft. The American Book Award. The Merle Curti for social history. The Langum for legal history. The Western History Association’s book prize. And now the grand Canadian one, the 2026 Cundill, worth seventy-five thousand dollars, the most lucrative history prize in the world.

“John Doe Chinaman” is the term Lew-Williams kept meeting in the archives — in the court records, in the census, in the newspapers. Record after record of that nameless Chinese man. Such anonymity, she argues, was purposefully manufactured by thousands of local and state laws governing where Chinese people could live, who they could marry, and whether they could testify against a white man in court.

A Chinese Jim Crow? Lew-Williams reminds us that the earliest racial zoning laws in America were aimed at the Chinese. So were the earliest restrictive covenants, written into deeds in the 1880s. First Chinese-Americans. Then African-Americans. The subtitle of John Doe Chinaman describes it as a “forgotten” history. No longer. This acclaimed book forces us to remember the humiliation of nameless Chinese immigrants like Lew-Williams’s YeYe.

ABOUT THE GUEST

Beth Lew-Williams is a professor of history at Princeton, where in 2014 she became the university’s first appointment in Asian American history. She grew up in Davis, California and took her doctorate at Stanford. Her first book, The Chinese Must Go: Violence, Exclusion, and the Making of the Alien in America, won two book prizes from the Organization of American Historians. John Doe Chinaman: A Forgotten History of Chinese Life under American Racial Law is published by Harvard University Press and won the 2026 Cundill History Prize, along with the Bancroft Prize, the American Book Award, the Merle Curti Social History Award, the David J. Langum Sr. Prize in American Legal History and the Western History Association’s book prize.

ABOUT KEEN ON AMERICA

Nobody asks more awkward questions than the Anglo-American writer and filmmaker Andrew Keen. With 3,000 episodes since the show launched on TechCrunch in 2010, Keen On America is a daily conversation about the ideas, books and arguments shaping the United States. New episodes every day.

CHAPTERS

00:00 — Intro
00:31 — AK: last year the shortlist, this year the winner
01:36 — Eight years, and a move from the border to the everyday
03:09 — The 1790 law, and racial ineligibility for citizenship
05:16 — Why she resists the comparison with anti-black violence
06:40 — 165 communities try to expel their Chinese neighbors, 1885–86
09:50 — Her YeYe, and an oral history two weeks before he died
11:15 — He asked her to turn off the tape recorder
13:53 — Chinatown as a product of segregation, not preference
16:30 — Japan complains about segregated schoolchildren, and America listens
17:24 — The first federal law to bar a group by race and class
19:06 — AK: so who was actually behind it?
21:01 — Heathen coolies: the stereotype behind the statutes
23:38 — Rock Springs, Wyoming, and the price per ton of coal
24:32 — AK: why John Doe Chinaman and not Heathen Coolies?
26:41 — Jim Crow, and influence running in both directions
28:40 — Restrictive covenants begin in the 1880s, against the Chinese
33:50 — What she wants people to think about is power
35:22 — Unable to naturalize from 1790 until 1943
38:00 — Alien land laws, then and now
38:53 — Closing