To Catch a Fascist: The Ethics of Unmasking the Radical Right
An anti-fascist spy handed American officials evidence of murderous intent from a Nazi planning server — and they declined to act.
About the Guest
Christopher Mathias is a journalist covering the far right, formerly a senior reporter at HuffPost, with work appearing in The Guardian, The Nation, MSNBC, Zeteo, and WNYC. His reporting has helped unmask white supremacist cops, soldiers, teachers, and politicians, and he was a Deadline Awards finalist for feature writing. He is originally from Gettysburg, Pennsylvania and lives in New York. His new book, To Catch a Fascist: The Fight to Expose the Radical Right (Atria Books), is out now.
About the Episode
Days after Jonathan Rauch’s influential Atlantic essay announced he’d moved from fascism skeptic to fascism believer, Christopher Mathias joins the show to discuss his new book — a deeply reported investigation into the decentralized network of anti-fascist activists who infiltrate, monitor, and expose neo-Nazis and white supremacists operating in positions of power across America.
The conversation quickly moves beyond whether Trump is a fascist to the harder questions his book raises: Who gets to decide who is exposed? What rights to privacy do members of extremist groups retain? Is unmasking community self-defense or vigilantism? And does the same logic that justifies exposing a neo-Nazi EMT extend to the tens of thousands of ICE agents now conducting raids on American streets?
Timeline
00:00 Introduction
Jonathan Rauch’s Atlantic essay and the renewed fascism debate
01:10 Meet Christopher Mathias
Introducing the book and the journalist behind it
01:45 The Greenville Moment
When Mathias first used “fascist” in a headline after watching Trump whip a crowd into chanting “Send her back”
02:40 Defining the F-Word
Fascism as a right-wing politics of domination; Langston Hughes recognizing it in the 1930s before the word arrived
04:15 The Hard Question
If MAGA is a fascist movement, are the 70-plus million who voted for Trump fascists too?
05:55 The Worst of the Worst
Why the book targets explicit neo-Nazis in positions of power, not ordinary Trump supporters
08:15 Who Decides?
Privacy, accountability, and whether everyone at Charlottesville deserves exposure
10:45 Antifascist Amnesty
Leave the movement and we leave you alone; return and we publish
12:30 The Equivalence Trap
Why Mathias rejects the idea that this is just radicals exposing radicals
14:05 From Neo-Nazis to ICE
How anti-fascist tactics are now used to identify masked federal agents
17:15 Where Does It End?
Drawing lines between violent enforcement and bureaucratic participation
19:40 “Just Following Orders”
Why some orders shouldn’t be followed, and the occupation of Minneapolis
21:30 The Battle Over Shame
Competing databases, surveillance, and what America should be ashamed of
23:15 The Spy Who Warned Charlottesville
An infiltrator uncovers plans for violence that officials ignore
26:00 Minneapolis as Model
“We protect us” and a blueprint for grassroots resistance
28:45 The Underground War
Intelligence, counterintelligence, and the personal cost of exposure
30:30 Closing
Fascism as a snake eating its own tail and the urgent task of limiting the damage
Links & References
Mentioned in this episode:
Jonathan Rauch, “Yes, It’s Fascism” — The Atlantic (January 2026)
Christopher Mathias reporting archive
Follow Christopher Mathias: BlueSky | X
About Keen On America
Nobody asks more impertinent questions than the Anglo-American writer, filmmaker and Silicon Valley entrepreneur Andrew Keen. In Keen On America , Andrew brings his sharp Transatlantic wit to the forces reshaping the United States — hosting daily interviews with leading thinkers
and writers about American history, politics, technology, culture, and business. With nearly 2,800 episodes since the show launched on TechCrunch in 2010, Keen On America is the most prolific intellectual interview show in the history of podcasting.
Website | Substack | YouTube
00:00 - Introduction
01:10 - Meet Christopher Mathias
01:45 - The Greenville moment
02:40 - Defining the F-word
04:15 - The hard question
05:55 - The worst of the worst
08:15 - Who decides?
10:45 - Antifascist Amnesty
12:30 - The equivalence trap
14:05 - From neo-Nazis to ICE
17:15 - Where does it end?
19:40 - “Just following orders”
21:30 - The battle over shame
23:15 - The spy who warned Charlottesville
26:00 - Minneapolis as model
28:45 - The underground war
30:30 - Closing
0:00 Hello, my name is Andrew Keen. Welcome to Keen on America, the Daily Show about everything that matters with the world's leading commentators and thinkers. Hello everybody. It is Wednesday, the 4th of February 20, 26, few days ago, and an old friend of the show, John Roush, had an influential essay on the Atlantic in which he announced he used to be a fascism skeptic.
0:46 And, uh, when it comes to the Trump regime, at least he believes that yes, it is indeed fascism. So, uh, uh, Donald Trump is indeed. August Company of Adolf Hitler and Benito Mussolini Elise, according to John. Uh, and I'm gonna try and get John back on the show actually to talk more about it. Uh, yesterday an interesting new book came out on the F word too. It's called to Catch a Fascist, uh, the Fight to Expose the radical right. It's by my guest today, Christopher Mathias uh, Chris, um, I'm assuming you're in the Roche camp, although I'm guessing also that you were never much of a skeptic.
1:29 Did you always believe that Trump was a fascist? Yeah. You know, I think, um, I think he certainly had those characteristics from the jump. Um, I think as a journalist, I probably didn't use the term myself in a headline until 20, uh, 18, 20 19. Um, it was actually a very specific, uh, scenario. I covered a Trump rally in Greenville, North Carolina, where I saw. The president, uh, whip the crowd into a frenzy, uh, over Ilhan Omar, and, uh, get the entire crowd to chant, send her back. Um, and, uh, I, I ended up writing an article immediately afterwards called a Fascist Trump rally in Greenville.
2:16 Uh, dur in which I, I kind of emailed a bunch of different scholars of fascism to ask for their take. Um, and yeah, so I guess I've been in the call using the f word camp for for a minute. So what, for you, I don't want to turn this into a, a scholastic discussion of fascism. Sure. Everyone has different definitions, but what for you distinguishes a fascist from. A conservative or just a reactionary? Yeah. You know, um. I guess it's, it's always a little tricky 'cause um, the, the way I kind of define fascism in the book, and it's kind of like my working definition obviously, um, but is kind of like a, a right wing politics of domination that sit situates a particular subgroup of people above a social hierarchy and then targets already marginalized groups for expulsion and, and death.
3:14 Um, all in this effort to kind of, you know, quote, purify or cleanse a, a nation to restore it to some mythical, uh, past of cultural and, and ethnic homogeneity. Um, and I think, you know. You could all, I think throughout, uh, the history of conservatism in America, it's always, you know, danced around the edges of explicit, uh, fascism. And, and I think, you know, something I try to get at in the book is that, um, in a way, um. Fascism was in America before, you know, we called it fascism. Um, Langston Hughes, uh, speaking at this writer's conference in the 1930s famously said like, you don't need to tell, uh, the black man in America about fascism.
4:03 We've, we, we are familiar with, uh, Nordic supremacy. Um, and its, and its, uh, trials. Um, so. I think when it comes to Trump and, and more recently using the F word, um, I think he basically took kind of a lot of maybe implicit or dog whistling, um, you know, racism, am bigotry and just made it that much more explicit. Um, and I think just exhibited, um, a lot of the characteristics that, um, I felt made him a fascist, and especially in the second administration and like your, uh. Friend, friend of the show wrote in the Atlantic.
4:44 Um, I think the, the evidence is just everywhere. Now. The original fascist, of course, Mussolini made the term up fascism, uh, Hitler, they were at one point, at least in their political careers, extremely popular. Mm-hmm. Uh, Trump seems to have some degree of popularity. At least he won the last election. Uh, in your view, if you believe that Trump. And his inner circle of fascists, does that make people who voted for him or the majority of people who voted for him, does that make them fascists too? You know, that's a, that's an interesting question. I think, um, I would certainly characterize MAGA at this point as a, as a fascist movement.
5:27 Um, and I think, um, it is something we should come to terms with. Um, you mean the like kind of explicit. Uh, racism not only in the last campaign, but uh, of this current administration is just so blatant and over the top. Um, I, um, I, you know, whether or not. It's interesting the way we use the word 'cause I don't think anyone in the Trump administration would necessarily self-identify as a fascist, even though there was that hilarious moment with, uh, Zohran Mamdani in, uh, the White House when Trump said, you know, call, call me a fascist.
6:07 It's fine. Um, uh, but. You know, as for calling individual Trump supporters, fascists. So I, I don't know. I mean, I think they're, I think they're swept, they're mixed up in something fascist for sure. Um, you know, this is kind of a distinction I make in the book, right? 'cause the book is about anti-fascist activists, um, who target, um. You know, what they see as fascist groups, um, for, you know, confrontation, for, uh, espionage, for research, for kind of unmasking members of, of fa of secretive fascist groups. Um, but you know, there. They're identifying these people, they're unmasking these people and calling them fascists, calling them Nazis, but they're not, you know, going to Trump rallies and I identifying Trump supporters as fascists or, you know, doxing them, exposing them.
6:57 Um, you know, they're kind of targeting the worst of the worst. Um, so yeah, I don't know. I, I think it's an interest. Interesting question. I'm not sure if you given it, it's an interesting question. I'm not sure if you fully answered it. Um, okay. What, what, what, what would, what would be your, your take on that? Well, I mean, of the, I don't know, however many million, 70, I don't know, 70, 80 million, a hundred million peop Americans who voted for Trump. Mm-hmm. Of those who, who, I mean, what a number of approximately 20, 30, 50% are fascists. I mean, it's an important question for better or worse. I mean, I, I, I know it's a hard one to answer.
7:40 Yeah. It's just, I, I mean, yeah, I don't know. It's, there's a lot to parse there, you know, I mean, like, uh, in, um, during the civil rights era, um, or I mean, if you go further back, I don't know, like during reconstruction in America, um. Like, could you arguably call? Um, I don't, I don't know what I'm getting at. I just, I just think it's, it's, it's a really hard thing to parse. Um, I think, uh, yes, I think they're part of a fascist movement. I don't know, um, if I would call them in particular. Each and every Trump supporter are fascist.
8:22 I mean, the reason I ask Chris is because your book is about the fight to expose the radical, right? And in part, I guess it's a kind of an exercise in, in doxing, uh, yeah, fascism. I mean, if there are 40 or 50 or 70 or a hundred million in Americans who voted for Trump, should they all be exposed? Should there be some sort of, sort of the, like the Vietnam. Uh, in Washington DC should there be a big wall or should there eventually be a big wall somewhere where these people are identified in terms of their support for Trump? Is that what you are arguing? And to catch a fascist, who's to to determine who gets to be exposed and who doesn't?
9:04 That's my question. Sure. Yeah. That's not what the book is arguing whatsoever. Um, that is, this is, have you read the book, Andrew? Yes. I've looked at it. You've looked at it. Sure. Okay. So the book is, um, you know. Basically about anti-fascist group, this kind of de antifa, you know, commonly the way we commonly call it, uh, the kind of this decentralized underground network of anarchists and, and socialists who, um, you know, don't trust. The state or law enforcement to combat, um, fascists in their communities. Um, so they do the work themselves and the large part of the work they're doing is exposing, you know, very explicit neo-Nazis and white supremacists.
9:53 These are members of groups like Identity Europa and Patriot Front, and a lot of the Nazis that marched in Charlottesville. Um, and they are doing the work to uncover the identities of, of these people, um, and, you know, often revealing them to be, um, men in positions of power. Um, and the idea of that is to kind of hold these people accountable is to say if you, for example, are, you know, one of the stories, uh, is about a, uh, Nazi EMT who runs a, one of the most. Popular neo-Nazi podcast in the country called The Daily Showa, the Showa, of course, being a, a word for the Holocaust. Um, and he is working as a paramedic as an EMT in Virginia.
10:38 Uh, on that podcast, he makes explicit references and stories to treating black patients differently. Anti-fascists expose this and becomes a, a story, and he. Gets fired. Um, there's another story, for example, of a neo-Nazi, a member of a group called Identity Aropa, which is very explicit about wanting to expel non-white people from America. Um, and. He, uh, is in Charlottesville. He's the security guard for Richard Spencer, who's kind of the, um, you know, poster boy of the, of the so-called alt-right in 2017. Um, and then he goes back to Massachusetts afterwards that, um, and he goes back to his job as a police officer, anti-fascist, figure out who he is.
11:23 Uh, they publish a, a docs or a story if you, if you will. Um, and he, you know, basically resigns before he is fired. So. From this perspective, this type of anti-fascist work is a form of community self-defense and accountability. And it's a way of kind of creating a social cost for being, you know, part of a, a fascist group. It's, it's kind of a way of saying like, yeah, you can join those groups if you want to, but, um, you know, you don't get to wear a mask. We're gonna figure out who you are and, and hold you accountable for it. The book, um. As you say is sympathetic to that aspect of the, the Antifa movement.
12:05 Um, and you, you know, in an interesting piece in the, in the nation that not, not all liberals are, are comfortable with that work of exposing people. What rights then do these individuals have when it comes to privacy, when should and shouldn't? Antifa have the right to expose these people. Uh, you talked about, we've done shows on Charlottesville. Should everyone who showed up for that rally in Charlottesville, should they be exposed? Should they lose their jobs? Should they be humiliated? Um, yeah, it's an interesting question. I think, um, you know, one of the. Groups I profile in the book, um, is is a group of anti-fascist researchers called Ignite The Right.
12:48 Um, ignite the Right is dedicated to doing exactly what you just said is to identifying and exposing everyone that was in Charlottesville. Um, and you know, I was in Charlottesville. I covered it as a reporter. Um, and. You know, I do not see, um, a way in which you attended that rally without, um, or participated in that rally without being an explicit neo-Nazi. Um, it was one of the most horrible things I've ever witnessed or experienced. Um, you know, I interviewed people, uh, after the car attack. I witnessed the beating of Deandre Harris. Um, and yes, I think if you attended that as, um.
13:32 A member of, like a participant in Unite the Right Rally. Yeah. You, you probably deserve some accountability. Does that mean that there isn't a, a like room or path for forgiveness or understanding? No, of course not. There, there's definitely an avenue for that. Um, I think one of the things I, you know, talk about in the book, um, is you know, this kind of, uh. Anti-fascists will often, you know, kind of do this thing called amnesty where, you know, they, if, if you're a Nazi and you're participating in something, but you've left the movement behind you, but you, you know, you might be exposed, you'll often go to these anti-fascists and be like, listen, I left these movement, this movement behind me.
14:12 And, and anti-fascists will be like, okay, yeah, well we won't do anything. You know, like, you know, we, we'll be honest though. Like if we see you mixed up in this again, we might. You know, post something. Um, so it's, I think it's just a method of, of, um, accountability. What about the accountability though of, of Antifa? I mean, who, who is to determine who's on these boards and who is exposing who it sounds to me, or to some liberals at least, it might sound as if, as a degree of moral. Equivalency here of one group of radicals exposing another group for being evil. I, I'm guessing that right wing radicals would probably have panels or groups or committers doing the same thing.
14:56 Yeah, no, totally. And, and um, you know, I think a lot of people will make that equivalency. Um, uh, you know. There is no board or leadership or headquarters for Antifa de despite what, um, the Trump administration, you know, might say. Um, it is typically, you know, decisions are arrived at locally and, and democratically and tediously. Um. And, you know, that's not to say they get it right every time. Um, uh, I do think that there is a big, I, you know, I, I will personally argue that there's not an equivalency between kind of right wing doxing and the, the doxing I describe in the book.
15:40 Um, you know, I think, um, you know. I am in support of unmasking and identifying, uh, fascists in, in my community and, um, would rather it not go the other way around. You wrote an interesting piece, uh, last week in The Guardian about Antifa unmasking, uh, not just neo-Nazis, but now members of, uh, ice, uh, the group of course, who very much in the news, in involved in there. Uh, in their violence on the streets of Minneapolis. Um, sh lots of debate about whether or not ICE agents or people who are working for ICE should have the right to anonymity.
16:28 What do you argue, uh, Chris in the book on catching a fascist in terms of ice in your view is everyone who works for ICE a fascist. You see, this is a, this is a kind of a, a distinction in terms that I think I don't, you know, get caught up in, like, I'm not identify, like I, I think it's worthy, uh, completely to identify the people in ICE right now. I think what ICE is doing right now is reprehensible, and I think it's, um, part of a. Pretty explicit project of ethnic cleansing. And I think it, you know, in, in my personal opinion, I think it meets every def definition of a fascist project. Um.
17:09 Now does, um, each individual, am I, you know, does each ice agent, are they a fascist? Um, you know, I don't know that they think of it consciously in that way or self-identify that way, but what I would say is that they are involved in a fascist project. Um, and I also think that they are, you know, kind of publicly funded. Um. Uh, you know, employees of, of the state, they're like kind of public officials in a way. Um, and that typically, you know, police aren't masked and they have to identify themselves. Um, and so I think it's a very kind of scary escalation that the people doing this, um, are wearing masks.
17:55 And I think, I think the reason, you know, uh, thank you for bringing up the Guardian article. You know, I think, um. Someone I interview in that says that the um reason. Um, that ice wear wears masks is 'cause they know what they're doing is, is unpopular or, you know, that it, um, might be wrong. Um, and I, and I think there's some, some truth to that. Um, and you know, I also just say I think it's really interesting, and this is something I try to, uh, bring up in the book, is that, you know, throughout the history of American. White supremacy, um, and specifically masked white supremacy.
18:38 Um, you know, you wear a mask in hopes of creating a world in which you won't need a mask at all. Um, the, the first Klan wears a mask to kind of terrorize black people in the south and to overthrow reconstruction to destroy the gains that, uh, recently freed black people have, have gained. When, when reconstruction is abandoned, um, you know, the Klan is isn't really needed anymore and it kind of disbands. That's part of the reason it disbands. Um, they kind of, you know. Trade the anonymity of the hood for the anonymity of the lynch mob. Um, and I think it's, uh, important and to consider the world, a world in which ICE agents, um, are comfortable carrying out what they're doing, uh, without a mask.
19:27 Um, and um, yeah, I think. That's the reason as the, um, the Guardian article you brought up, uh, you know, mentions is that anti-fascists have, uh, you know, kind of changed their targets and are identifying ice agents in Minneapolis and, and elsewhere. The article also, uh, quotes, uh, people who argue that you need to identify all. Ice and, and DHS officers, that's the homeland security, uh, department. Those are many thousands of people. Chris isn't, aren't there? I mean, how, how is, firstly, how's that gonna work?
20:09 And secondly, it's, it's, it's, it's, it's targeting. I, I think. I think you might be misreading. I think it's targeting border patrol agents active in the missions in Minneapolis on the streets to kind of abduct people off the street. There are many thousands of those. Uh, I mean they're not just on the street, they're on the streets of Los Angeles. They're on the border, there are in Minneapolis. Who knows where else they are. There are, mm-hmm. Many thousands of these agents. Are you suggesting in the book that. Uh, leaving aside the F word that they should all be somehow exposed, that everyone should know what they're doing and shamed, essentially. Um, so the, the book was written before the current kind of escalation of, of ice.
20:54 Um, so I don't make an argument about that, although I'm guessing that this doesn't necessarily surprise you what's happened on the streets of Minneapolis. No, not at all. I mean, I think it is, um, exactly what, um. MAGA and, and Trump have promised to do. I mean, if you're going to promise to Massport, uh, millions and millions and millions of people, of our neighbors and friends and and loved ones, it's gonna look like this and it's gonna be, um, a spectacle. Um, you know, I think, uh. Steven Miller, who I think a lot of reporting suggests this is kind of his brainchild and, and project. Mm-hmm. Um, you know, he is, um, steeped in, in a kind of explicit white supremacist literature.
21:41 Um, and, you know, he was, his emails were leaked, um, to the Southern Property Law Center years back, and they showed him just kind of swimming in these, uh, you know, waters online of, um, you know, kind of. Explicit great replacement talk of, of the, the term Remi, which is really just a euphemism for ethnic cleansing. Um, and you know, of ado of, you know, kind of promoting books like Camp of Saints, which of course is like, you know, this really kind of racist, dystopian, uh, novel. Um, so. Um, no. I mean, sadly I think like there's, um, no, and I take your point on, on Miller.
22:21 I mean, I wouldn't argue with you on Miller, although everybody knows who he is, he doesn't wear a mask. Right. My question was about the tens of thousands of, of ice agents who presumably, some of them at least, are looking for work and their. Doing that, they're working for the state in, in the way in which many Americans have done historically. Would you distinguish, I mean, is everyone who works for ice, should they all be exposed or is there only ice agents on the streets or those who are violent? How are we gonna know? Well, I mean, that's what, what's happening. The, the current kind of grassroots effort to identify ice, you know, they're not identifying like.
23:01 Administrative people or, you know, I think there's actually, um, there's a site called isis, which isn't like an Antifa project per se, but they, they make this distinction, I think, and I think this is what you're getting at, which is that like they're not going to identify the people. Working the daycare at, you know, DHS, uh, taking care of government, employees, kids, um, like they're, and they're not gonna, you know, docs or unmask the everyday employees necessarily of DHSI think they are so far, at least what they've done and, and what I've detailed in the article is that they are. Identifying people that have taken place in, or taken part in a particularly bad or, or brutal bits of, uh, violence or kind of especially, um, egregious, uh, you know, um.
23:48 Abductions or deportations, whatever, whatever you wanna call them. I think, you know, one of the officers that's identified in, in my article is someone who pepper sprayed a protestor at point blank range. Um, one of the, some of the other people that they've identified were the agents seen, uh, bringing an elderly man, uh, out of his house, shirtless and like zero degree temperature as his grandchild with out the window. Um, you know, I think they are. Targeting, uh, those people. Um, you know, I don't really see them nor, nor would they necessarily have the resources at this point to identify, you know, the thousands of employees of of DHS.
24:30 I think they are creating accountability for, you know, the people committing kind of the most egregious acts. And, and how would you respond to, uh, an ice agent? I don't suppose one would appear on this show. Probably not show their face certainly, but mm-hmm. Who would simply say, well, we're just doing our job and we we're trying to, uh, uh, obey the rules of the state when it comes to immigration. Sure. Um. Yeah, I mean that it, it sounds almost trite to say, but you know, we're just doing our job sounds a lot like we're just following orders. Um, you know, which of course, um, you know, I think in moments like this, it's, it's important to say that, you know, there are some orders that shouldn't be followed.
25:21 Um, and what is happening, you know, particular, particularly in Minneapolis, um, you know, from all accounts of, from the people living there is. A straight up occupation. Um, I think there's been reports, um, uh, I think maybe in EO or elsewhere, uh, kind of detailing, um, that morale is not necessarily high within ICE at the moment. Um, and I think they see that this huge community uprising in response, um. You know, they, they know how unpopular they are and that they might have to live with the shame of what they're a part of for a while, um, you know, we're, we're seeing the popularity of, of ice and this project of these deportations just kind of plummeted in the polls.
26:13 And a, a phrase like abolish ice, which, you know, year, a few years ago, I think was, felt like pretty radical. Um, is reaching an all time record high, um, even 20% of Republicans support. Um, abolishing ICE at this point, or support that phrase, I believe. Um, so, um, yeah, I'm, I'm sorry. I, I, I forgot your initial question, but, um, no, I, I think you answered it. Um, yeah. So for you or perhaps for the anti Antifa group, and, and maybe this is, this is a compelling argument, shame is, is, is a powerful political tool. Yeah.
26:54 Yeah. No, I, I think, I think that's really it. And, um, I'm, I'm glad you put it that way 'cause I've been thinking a lot about it this week because Tom Homan, of course, the, um, the, the head of ice at the moment. Yeah. Um, he, uh, recently came out with a statement where he, he tried to kind of flip my book on, its. Uh, on its side, right? He said like, you know, we are, we're filming the people that are standing up against ICE and we're gonna create a database and they're gonna be shamed and they're gonna lose their jobs. So like, there is like, you know, in a way, I think, and I'm so glad you phrased the question that way, Andrew. Um, there is like, kind of this battle over, um, shame and, and, and what we're supposed to be ashamed of.
27:35 Um, and I think, um. It's just a, it's a push and, and, and a pull. It's a, it's a, it's a, it's a real fight. So what becomes, as I said, you've been quite critical, I think of conventional liberals when it comes to this stuff. What becomes of our right to privacy is that only people who are moderates who have a right to privacy or people on the left. You know, I think the, the argument for, um. Unmasking, kind of straight up. Fascist is just a form of community self-defense. It's to know that the people, there are people in your community that are explicitly calling for violence online, that are, that are liable, uh, to commit violence.
28:26 Um, you know, one of the stories I tell in the book, um. And I will, you know, admit, like this is not like a, from the kind of militant, anti-fascist perspective, um, you know, they have a, uh, a different approach to concepts of, of freedom of speech than, than your kind of more moderate liberal, um. You know, one of the stories I tell in the book is that an anti-fascist spy goes into, um, the planning server for the Unite the Right Rally in Charlottesville, where all these Nazi groups are planning, um, the event and this spy collects reams of data, of memes and messages, just kind of evidence of these Nazis murderous intent for that day.
29:13 Um. He gives them to local anti-fascists in Charlottesville, who then give them to the local city government, uh, pleading with, um, you know, the mayor, the, the council to revoke these Nazis permit, uh, for their rally. Um, you know, the officials decide not to do that. Um, uh, and of course, you know, what happens in Charlottesville happens, um, and I think from like the militant, anti-fascist perspective, like. You know, these fascists always pose an inherent threat when they're allowed to organize. Um, and, um, it's a fight to, um, you know, to stop their violence from happening.
29:59 And, and part of that work is unmasking them and, uh, knowing who they are, um, you know, in the pre-internet era. This anti-fascist work in America in the eighties and nineties, often involved activists like digging through the dumpsters of like neo-Nazis houses and fi, and finding discarded mail and finding their real names and then posting, you know, meet your local Nazi posters on telephone poles. Um, so, but back to your original question, like who is deserving of privacy? Um, you know, I think we are. All deserving of privacy. But I think if you are actively, you know, agitating as part of a movement to expel a good portion of this country for not being white, um, then it's a matter of kind of actual community self defense to know who those people are.
30:58 I love the title of the book. Um. Uh, yeah, it reminds me, of course, uh, your book is called, uh, to Catch a Fascist, uh, Hitchcock's 1952, uh, or 1955 movie to Catch a Thief with Carrie Grant and Grace Kelly. Very different, which, which I, which I still haven't watched. I I should Oh, you haven't watched it yet. It's, it's, it's very different. Are you? And it, and of course it's a fun movie and a romantic movie. Are you optimistic now given? What happened on the streets of Minneapolis? Do you feel that the worst is over, Chris? Yeah, you know, I, I really don't know. I think, um, we've had so many moments like this where, um, you know, 'cause we did in a sense see Trump like retreat a little bit in Minneapolis, right?
31:46 Like he dispatched with Bovino, you know, kind of the guy in charge that who really dressed like a Nazi. Um, but, um. Uh, you know, we also know that abductions and these kind of deportations are taking place all over right now, still in places like Los Angeles and even in New York, um, where I am and, um. All I can say is that, um, what we saw in Minneapolis, I personally found very heartening. Um, it was like an organic grassroots response, uh, by the people there to say that, you know, this is not acceptable. Um, and it reminded me a lot of the kind of grassroots.
32:33 Militant anti-fascist response to the wave of fascist groups and Nazi groups that marched on the streets of America in 2017 and 2018, where you are confronting these people in the streets, you're following them, you're monitoring them, you're identifying them, you're pressuring venues and hotels, not to host them. Um, you know, it's just creating a social cost. And we, we've seen that. All over Minneapolis. And I think it's working and I think it's providing a, a model of, uh, resistance, um, for across the country. So in, in that way, yes, I, um, feel optimistic. I think, you know, one of the, uh, mantras, uh, that.
33:15 A couple mantras or axioms that you hear in anti-fascist circles are, uh, we protect, we protect us. Um, and I think Minneapolis showed that, you know, they weren't relying on the law enforcement. They weren't relying on the Democratic party or their local government to defend, uh, themselves against ice and defend their neighbors against ice. They, they realized that it was up to them to defend their, their neighbors. Um, you know, and then the other expression you hear a lot, um. Maybe, you know, I just have Woody Gut three on the Mind, but is, uh, you know, all you fascist bound to lose. Um, and I do think, um, you know, that fascism is ultimately a self-destructive ideology.
33:57 'cause it constantly needs to manufacture new targets and new subgroups to, to scapegoat and, and eliminate. Um, and until eventually, you know, there's no one left, it's kind of like eating its own. I, I do this. Fascist moment that this fascist movement is bound to lose. It's just kind of what's important right now is to stop this movement from doing as much destruction as as possible. So you seem to be saying two things. On the one hand, it's gonna eat itself, so we could just leave it alone. On the other hand, you seem, and, and correct me if I'm wrong, to be suggesting that in, in some ways these people, or at least their views should be illegal. So I'm, I'm, I'm not saying they should be illegal.
34:39 Um, I'm saying that there should be consequences. I think one of the analogies that I draw in the book is, um, let's say you're in a bar. And a, um, guy comes in and starts, uh, shouting racial slurs, maybe throws up a, a Nazi salute. Um, you, there's a recognition that that guy poses a threat, that he's liable to do something and you're gonna ask him to leave. Um, if he doesn't leave, uh, you might for, you might force him to leave. Um, I think. I, I, I, I feel like your question's kind of around freedom of speech. Am am I correct, Andrew or? Yes. Yes. Yeah, yeah. Okay.
35:19 Yeah. So I think, um, there's the distinction I think maybe I'm trying to draw here is not like freedom of speech doesn't mean freedom from consequences. Um, you know, it like if you say racist shit in a bar, you're liable to get, get punched. Um, and you know, I. I don't know if that's a, a bad thing. Uh, tomorrow we've got, uh, lawyer, uh, Andrew Guthrie Ferguson. He has a new book out called Your Data Will Be Used Against You. Are you at all concerned, Chris, that, that the, the tactics that you are supporting in this new book to catch a fascist will be used by the right against guys like yourself or certainly members of Antifa?
36:08 Uh, sure. Yeah. I mean the, um, it's, uh, I mean, it's, it is essentially, well, I think what you're touching on is that, and what I describe in my book is that it is essentially an underground war of intelligence and counterintelligence. It's kind of an informal, uh, uh, intelligence agencies that a war with each other, if you will. There, there, there definitely are far right efforts and right-wing efforts to identify anti-fascist activists. Um. And, you know, there are websites to that effect. Um, you know, we also saw during the, um, uh, uprisings and the protests against, uh, the genocide in Gaza, that there were websites like Canary Mission that were identifying, um, uh, you know, members of those demonstrations.
36:53 Uh, there's a website called Antifa Watch, uh, which claims to identify members of Antifa. Um, I personally have been doxed, um, and, you know. By doxed, I mean, um, you know, when I, when I say dox in the anti-fascist sense, I mean the kind of the digital equivalent of ripping the white hood off of a Klansman. Um, when I say I personally was doxed, it means, you know, my, um, phone number and address and that of my families was posted online and we all received death threats and I had to file police reports. Um, so that is definitely already happening. Um. I will say that I think the left, um, is much better and much more careful at it as a project.
37:37 Um, the right often mis identifies people all the time or is very sloppy, um, sloppy with it. Um, and you know, I think when the right does it, they often do it as a way of inviting, um, real harassment and, and violence. Um. Uh, whereas I think, you know, a lot of the anti-fascist docs as I described in my book, um, you know, sometimes they might post a Nazis address, but most of the time they're not. Um, so yeah. Um, it's, it's, it's definitely kind of already happening. It's, it's a bit of a battle. It certainly is a bit of a battle, uh, interesting conversation. The book is out.
38:17 It was out yesterday to catch a fascist. The fight to expose the radical. Right. Very interesting. And I'm gonna bring the book up when I talk to, uh, Andrew Ferguson tomorrow. Congratulations, Chris on the new book and continue with your good work. Thank you so much. Thanks so much for having me, Andrew. This was a pleasure.