Feb. 9, 2026

Rage in the American Republic

Rage in the American Republic
Keen On America
Rage in the American Republic

"We all love Thomas Paine. We just wish we liked him." — Jonathan Turley

Jonathan Turley's new book asks a deceptively simple question: why did the American Revolution become the longest-running successful democracy while the French Revolution devoured itself? The answer, he argues, lies in Madison's "auxiliary precautions" — constitutional safeguards designed not to eliminate rage but to channel it. Turley draws a direct line from Robespierre to today's calls to pack the Supreme Court and abolish the Senate, warning that removing those precautions invites the same mobocracy that sent the Jacobins to the guillotine. But the real provocation comes in the book's second half: with AI and robotics threatening mass unemployment, America may soon face a "kept population" — citizens subsidized by the state who lose their vital relationship to productivity and self-governance. We discuss Thomas Paine (brilliant about humanity, clueless about humans), why rage itself isn't the enemy, and whether the republic built to handle the 18th century can survive the 21st.

About the Guest

Jonathan Turley is the Shapiro Professor of Public Interest Law at George Washington University Law School. A legal analyst for CBS, NBC, BBC, and Fox News over three decades, he is the author of The Indispensable Right (a bestseller) and the new Rage and the Republic: The Unfinished Story of the American Revolution.

Chapters:

00:01:14 The uniqueness of the American Revolution
Two revolutions, two outcomes; Thomas Paine and James Madison as the twin geniuses

00:03:53 Paine vs. Madison on democracy
Paine wanted direct democracy; it nearly got him guillotined in France

00:05:54 Robespierre's transformation
The ACLU lawyer who came to believe "terror is virtue"

00:09:01 Thomas Paine: the penman of the revolution
From complete failure to revolutionary genius in two years

00:11:46 Slavery and the revolution's contradictions
Why people preferred Jefferson to Paine

00:15:43 Franklin's greatest achievement
Seeing something in "that heap of human wreckage"

00:18:07 What was unique about American rage
Not the rage itself, but the system designed to handle it

00:25:08 The "New Jacobins"
Calls to pack the Supreme Court and abolish the Senate

00:26:40 Rage on both sides
"Your rage is righteous, their rage is dangerous"

00:30:47 AI and the "kept population"
Mass unemployment and the citizen's relationship to the state

00:39:26 "Gynan" jobs
Homocentric industries like psychiatry and education that AI can't replace

00:45:00 Why the American Republic is still the best model
Decentralization over EU-style centralization

References

Figures discussed:

  • Thomas Paine — arrived in America "barely alive," became the penman of the revolution in two years
  • James Madison — designed the "auxiliary precautions" that prevented American democracy from devouring itself
  • Benjamin Franklin — paid for Paine's passage to America, saw genius in "that heap of human wreckage"
  • Maximilien Robespierre — began as an advocate for due process, ended declaring "terror is virtue"
  • Jean-Paul Marat — radical journalist, killed by Corday in his bathtub (he bathed constantly due to a skin disease)
  • Charlotte Corday — Republican who assassinated Marat; Robespierre and Danton watched her execution
  • Georges Danton — joined the moderate Girondin wing; executed by the revolution he helped create


Art:

  • The Death of Marat (1793) — Jacques-Louis David's painting of Marat's assassination; David was himself a Jacobin


Historical events:


Books mentioned:

About Keen On America
Nobody asks more impertinent questions than the Anglo-American writer, filmmaker and Silicon Valley entrepreneur Andrew Keen. In Keen On America , Andrew brings his sharp Transatlantic wit to the forces reshaping the United States — hosting daily interviews with leading thinkers and writers about American history, politics, technology, culture, and business. With nearly 2,800 episodes since the show launched on TechCrunch in 2010, Keen On America is the most prolific intellectual interview show in the history of podcasting.

Website

Substack

YouTube

Apple Podcasts

Spotify

01:14 - The Uniqueness of the American Revolution

03:53 - Paine vs. Madison on Democracy

05:54 - Robespierre's Transformation

09:01 - Thomas Paine: The Penman of the Revolution

11:46 - Slavery and the Revolution's Contradictions

15:43 - Franklin's Greatest Achievement

18:07 - What Was Unique About American Rage

25:08 - The "New Jacobins"

26:40 - Rage on Both Sides

30:47 - AI and the "Kept Population"

39:26 - "Gynan" Jobs

45:00 - Why the American Republic is Still the Best Model

0:00 Hello, my name is Andrew Keen. Welcome to Keen on America, the Daily Interview Show about the United States. Hello everybody. It's Monday. February the eighth, 2026. GW Law School seems to be monopolizing the Keenon America Show these days.

0:41 Few days ago we had Andrew Guthrie Ferguson, a professor at GW talking about his new book. Your Data will be used against you, a kind of libertarian defense against the leviathans of Silicon Valley, and now we have another GW professor, Jonathan Turley, who like Ferguson, has a new book ad, it's called Rage in the Republic, the Unfinished Story of the American Revolution. It's just out his, uh, last book. Many of you'll be familiar with. The Indispensable Ride was a best seller. Uh, expect this one will be two. Jonathan is joining us from his home.

1:22 Uh, in the Washington DC area. Uh, Jonathan, would it be fair to say that your new book, uh, Rage in the Republic, uh, focuses on the uniqueness of the American Revolution, which of course we are celebrating the 250th year anniversary this year? Well, first of all, Andrew, thank you for having me on your program, and it does indeed look at what are the factors and the personalities and events that came together to create this unique republic 250 years ago. And that first half of the book looks at two revolutions, the American and French revolutions, and actually follows much of the journey of Thomas Payne, uh, who is one of two central figures who played a role in both revolutions.

2:16 The other being Lafayette. And the, the first half of the book sort of tries to figure out why the American Revolution went on to become the longest, uh, and most successful democracy, and the French Relu revolution went on to become the reign of terror. And what, what the book suggests is that the difference were these precautions that James Madison put together, uh, in the constitution. You know, Thomas Payne was the righteous rage of, uh, the American Revolution. It may have been the truest revolutionary of the American Revolution, and it was James Madison who was sort of the pious logic.

3:00 You know, Payne knew what it would take. To move a people to revolution. And then Madison knew what it would take to move a revolution to a republic. And it was the combination of those two sort of mindsets and two, frankly, two geniuses that produced this republic. And then the second half of the book looks forward as to whether that republic can survive in the 21st century. And it looks at everything from the combination of robotics and ai. Which I go into some depth on, uh, and the potential of a massive loss of jobs as well as global governance and the rise of what I call the class of new Jacobins.

3:46 Well, we'll get to that class of new Jacobins in in a few minutes. Um, Jonathan, is your analysis there, and it sounds to me as if your analysis of the American Revolution is. Somewhat burkey in this one, two punch of pain. And then Madison, Madison forcing pain's, anger, and righteousness to into law. You are a professor of law. I I, I Is that fair? Is, is your analysis of the uniqueness of the American Revolution, Bian Burke, of course, being the greatest of all critics of the French Revolution and particularly of Jacobin? Well, I go to some depth about the. Uh, the debate between Payne and Burke, I'm known as a more of a Madisonian scholar, and the book certainly embraces what Madison was arguing.

4:35 What I find fascinating about Thomas Payne, and he is the most interesting historical figure I've ever researched or written about is that pain. Was a remarkable individual, a true genius, but he did not agree with Madison's auxiliary precautions as he called them, uh, because he believed more in direct democracy. And when he went to the French Revolution, he pursued that with Jacobins. He wanted a unicameral legislature. Uh, he wanted to sort of strip away a lot of those barriers for the public to express themselves through legislation. And it came damn near to killing him that his pain came within 24 hours of being guillotine.

5:18 Uh, and it was just an accident that he wasn't beheaded, but he came to realize that Madison was right. And what he was, what the, the rightness of Madison was in the view that democracies devour themselves. Uh, that at the beginning of the book starts by quoting a Frenchman from the Revolution, uh, who said that revolutions like Saturn develop, devour their own. Yeah. And of course there's that famous novel, the Gods must Have Their Blood. That's right. And pain Watch that happen. In France, uh, the Jacobins, all the leadership of the Jacobins, except for a couple of notable exceptions, all fell under what was called, uh, the Razor of the Republic.

6:04 They all were devoured by the revolution. And of course, the razor was not just metaphorical, it was the guillotine. I, I'm guessing. Um. Jonathan, the, the, uh, the bad guy in, in your narrative, at least when it comes to France, is, is Robe spear? Does he speak for everything that went wrong with the French Revolution? Well, I go into depth with robes. Pierre and I talk about him in the second half as well. Who would tell you about the new Jack of them? What has to be remembered is that Rob Spear was a lawyer, and when he began, uh, he spoke about the rights of man, about due process. Uh, if you had heard him and read him in the early days, you would've thought he was an A CLU lawyer. And this, yeah. I'm guessing, uh, do you, do you get the Rob Spear types in your classes at gw?

6:48 I'm sure you shut them up, Jonathan, don't you? Well, you know, the, the thing about it is I, I not only talk about roast beer, but also figures like morat. Uh, journalists, uh, lawyers, professors, aristocrats, uh, who began in the same way but were corrupted over time to the point that Robe Pierre eventually said that terror is virtue. Uh, he came to totally embrace. The execution of those that disagree with you. And the book talks about how this was sort of a rousso revolution in that sense. The, the Jacob Ins loved Rousseau and his idea of the general will, and this was another way of saying direct democracy, that if you unleash the general will of the populace, that it can only come to good because people are good.

7:34 It was a very naive, yeah. And of course, Rousseau invented the modern concept of. Authenticity and the self and all, all the rest of, uh, that, um, were there any good guys in your. Analysis of the French Revolution. Dante, of course, comes to mind. Uh, who got the French Revolution in France? Tocqueville, I'm guessing from your point of view. Well, the top villain will definitely have to go to Rose Pierre and Marat and Abe and a few others. But I, you know, downtown was no angel. Of course, he, he signed off on the executions. Eventually he joined, um, the. Uh, which was the sort of moderate Jacobin wing, but they had blood on their hands as well.

8:20 And then ultimately, of course, he was executed. It was an interesting, you know, many of the good ones were of course, executed, uh, because they were good. Uh, the gods must have their blood, Jonathan, that's right. In your historical narrative. The way, uh, we, when, when I was a. A student in England, the way we were brought up in terms of our analysis of these comparative revolutions is we didn't begin with the French or the American revolutions. We began with the glorious English revolution. What's your analysis when it comes to rage and the republic of. The Republican Revolution, or what in part was a Republican revolution in England, the Cromwellian Revolution, which of course was also manifested by a degree of rage.

9:06 What was different from the American Revolution? Well, this is a book about revolutions. I do talk about the English revolution. I. All revolutions require rage. All these nations are not just the progeny of Revolution, uh, but the result of rage. That's what the Boston Tea Party was after all, it was rage, and you have to move a country to rage. That's why Thomas Payne was so important. That's why he's called the penant of the revolution. It's why he's so extraordinary. I mean, he arrived in this country, barely alive after a voyage, had to be carried off a ship in Philadelphia. That was two years. Just two years before the Declaration of Independence, in two years, he went from being a, an entire and complete failure in everything he had ever done.

9:52 Every job, every marriage he had to being the penman of the American Revolution. But the American Revolution was the first true enlightenment revolution. Um, not to downplay the English, uh, rebellion. You don't consider it a revolution. You just, you call it a rebellion, Jonathan. Well, I don't mean that king. No, I did, I didn't actually mean much by the, the, the, uh, um, change in, in, in nouns. But the, uh, the American Revolution was, was a direct outgrowth. Of enlightenment ideas. And the Declaration of Independence is largely an enlightenment document. It actually doesn't talk about democracy. It talks about liberty.

10:33 It never mentions democracy. And in that sense it was a fascination for, for people around the world. Uh, you know, they talked about. These Americans, like they were a brand new species. And it sort of goes when lock said in the beginning, all was America. It was not just that this was an untamed land, uh, it was this notion that this was a country that was starting anew without the sort of calcified structures classes of Europe. And I talk in the book about a Frenchman who wrote under the name, uh, farmer John. Who had a great line and a very popular book in Europe, and he asked, what then is this America?

11:17 And it was a very profound question. But then is this American? They, the, the, the, the Europeans wanted to know, uh, how this could happen, why it happened. And actually the French modeled originally the revolution on, on the United States, but then refused to create those protections and precautions. Uh, they wanted the revolution, but not what came with it. Jonathan. Um, what about the alternative narrative of the American Revolution? I'm sure you are not particularly keen on it. The idea of the appropriation of indigenous land, the history of slavery in terms of the American Revolution.

12:01 Are there contradictions, especially when it comes to pain? Pain of course, was not an admirer of slavery, perhaps even of capitalism. Um, what about. The alternative narratives, do you just dismiss them? No, I don't. In fact, I talk about those, the inherent contradictions are glaring. I actually talk about it also in terms of why Thomas Payne was so unpopular. You know, he had the distinction of being. Pursuit for prosecutions in all three nations where he claimed citizenship, uh, forced sedition. Uh, he was the ultimate contrarian. But there was more to that, as I say in the book, that there's a reason why.

12:43 People preferred figures like Thomas Jefferson, the Thomas Payne Jefferson was tall and erudite. Uh, classically trained, well educated, and a slave owner, Thomas Payne, was vehemently against slavery. And that, I think, contributed to his being an out outlier. I mean, it was, so, there were others that were against slavery, but it was this glaring contradiction that pain himself did not have, which is why I think he's such a, a redeeming character. Um, even if he had very few friends, you know, uh, I, I quote, uh, Benjamin Franklin's daughter is saying it would've been better if he had died right after common Sense.

13:25 And I note in the book, she was one of his friends. So, you know, it, it, it's an amazing thing about pain. He, he died, uh, virtually friendless, of course penniless, which was the problem he had his entire life. But slavery is one of those big issues that is looming here in terms of the contradictions, particularly if you are an enlightenment. Revolution to deny those freedoms to so many who were enslaved by you. And, and that book does talk about that. It's interesting you bring up Franklin. We've done a number of shows on him, uh, over the years. Um, Franklin, of course, was the reverse. Of pain in the sense that he had many friends both in the United States and Europe.

14:08 Is he your fourth man, Jonathan? We've got, uh, Madison, we've got Jefferson, we've got pain. Who's the kind of, I don't know what you'd call him, it sounds to me like a kind of anti-hero, simultaneously hero and anti-hero in your narrative. What about Franklin? Well, pain is remarkably and delightfully. Complex. Uh, you know, I quote in the book, I'm a film noir nut and I drive my children crazy 'cause I, I have to have something playing in the background when I work. And it's always a black and white film noir film, which, which probably scarred my children, uh, to, to a terrible, I just hope so. Yeah. And, uh, but the greatest line ever uttered in any film noir.

14:49 Was delivered by Fred Murray who turned after finding out that the femme fatal had finally lied to him again, as well as to her husband, uh, and she was incapable of telling the truth. He goes to the door, she begs him to stay, and he turns and says, I love you so much. I only wish I liked you. And I think with Thomas Payne, for those of us who have spent a lot of time with him, uh, in, in these histories, um, we all love him. We just wish we liked him. He, he, he had this person was hard to like, because in many ways he was brilliant about humanity, but he was clueless about human. Uh, and the, the, the, the classic conservative critique of leftist for people who are just listening.

15:32 Jonathan is very formal fellow. He is dressed in a suit and ties a wannabe Thomas Payne in you, uh, Jonathan, do you sometimes wake up in the middle of the night and fantasize of being Thomas Payne? I can't say I fantasize being Thomas Payne. But What about your wife would you like, would she like you to be Thomas Payne? Oh, I don't think anyone would wanna live with Thomas Payne. You know, the interesting you mentioned about George be exciting though for a few minutes, wouldn't it? Yeah. But you know, it's, um, it only took a few minutes before people generally got into a fight with Thomas Payne 'cause he was the ultimate contrarian. And you mentioned Benjamin Franklin, who is, is, is, is prominently featured in the book and the ladies loved, uh.

16:14 Franklin and Franklin, of course, loved the ladies, especially the French ladies, I think. Yes. And, and the interesting thing is that Thomas Payne had finally hit rock bottom. Uh, he had no money. He, he appeared before Benjamin Franklin in London without a penny unkempt, uh, known as a drunkard and, uh, a contrarian. Benjamin Franklin saw something in that heap of human wreckage, which is a skill that Benjamin Franklin had. He had an eye for talent, but his greatest achievement without question was Thomas Payne. He was the one who paid for Thomas Payne to go to America. He was the one who wrote his son the governor, to ask that he find a position for him.

16:59 He was the one that told Thomas Payne, you should write. And it, and in many ways the book looks at Thomas Payne because he may be the quintessential American. He came to this shore to reinvent himself to become something new. And what he found was in this place that he said that there was a special something in the United States. And I think that's special something. Is a place without limits. And he came to reinvent himself and he did, he discovered that the most valuable thing he had was, in his head, it was being Thomas Payne. Yeah. And of course, uh, Fitzgerald famously said he was completely wrong on this, that there are no second chances in America.

17:44 And Thomas Payne had a second chance. And then perhaps that's what America's all about. Let's get to the R word. Um. Uh, Jonathan Rage are, are you arguing in the book that there's something uniquely American, or at least, uh, uniquely American about rage in the American Revolution? I mean, all our revolutions you've noted are, are driven by rage. That was a rageful, as you note about Thomas pain and anger. Thirst for justice. What is so unique about the rage driving the American Revolution? That thirst for justice.

18:25 Of course, you can find not just with robes beer, with Lenin, with Mao, with many other revolutions. There's nothing unique about the rage in, in, uh, the American Revolution. That's the point of the book that, that rage is, is a very human feeling. It's my second book that deals with my f the, the earlier book that you mentioned dealt with the, what I call the Age of Rage and Yeah. And the subtitle of the book is Free Speech In An Age of Rage. Yeah. But it's not our first age of rage and. It's not unique. But what was unique was the recognition of the founders. They did not want an Athenian democracy, which was utter failure. It, it lasted not that very long and, and ended up in tyranny.

19:10 They did not want what one framer called a mo that the tendency of democracies to devour themselves. So what was unique was the. Effort put in to create a system that could vent the pressures, that would blow democracies apart, that could handle the rage. That's what was unique, not the rage itself. And, and that's of course Madison and, uh, the other authors of the Federalist Papers. Then are you arguing that the key event perhaps in the revolution was the debate? Articulated in the Federalist papers about a centralized government versus something else. Well, what I talk about, particularly the second half of the book and trying to identify the elements that led us to create this republic is that we're gonna need them more than ever in the 21st century.

20:00 And many of those are Madisonian. Precautions. You know, I do a sort of, the first half is sort of a tale of two cities. I look at Philadelphia and Paris. Both had violence in the street. This was after the American Revolution. Paris was about to get blown apart again. Uh, there was an attack called the Battle of Fort Wilson. It was actually just James Wilson's home. He came damn near close, one of the founders to being killed by a mob. And many people died, but then it stomped in Philadelphia. That's a true miracle about it. And even though the Constitution was unpopular, it barely passed in Pennsylvania, people discovered that they had an alternative to going into the streets and it's stabilized.

20:45 That's what was missing. The French Revolution and it take, it takes a lot. When you unleash that rage, it takes a lot. You know, starting revolutions is not as as difficult as ending one. You know, Napoleon Bonaparte, of course, was the result of the French Revolution, but it's Bonaparte. That said, a revolution is an idea that has found its bayonets. The problem is defined a way to put the bayonets away when you have accomplished or articulated that idea, and that's what the French were unable to do. It required a shock. To them to end the bloodletting. You know, you talk about the figures from the French Revolution. One that I spend a lot of time on is, is Corde, who is this beautiful woman who killed Marat in his bathtub and it was famously famous painting.

21:36 Yeah. Yes. With David, the death of, of Marat. Um, David was himself a radical jack of the. Him and, and this was sort of a propaganda piece he had do, he had Marat laid out like a Piet in the tub with alabaster skin. You know, Marat was in the tub 'cause his, he was covered in sores 'cause he had a rare skin disease. And, uh, he, he most likely did not look quite as contented as, uh, have a knife plunged into his chest, but corde in many ways. Was a shock to the system. Uh, her execution was different from the rest. Uh, people found her courage and not just her beauty to be, uh, really sort of, um, all encompassing and watching her execution was robes.

22:26 Pierre next to him was Dante, both of which would soon fall under the same blade. And I, but Corde was, I think one of those turning points. She was a Republican. She was not, uh, a royalist in that sense. She had seen the bloodletting and wanted to end it, and, but she ended it with an act of assassination. You mentioned earlier that you're a, a Madison scholar. Madison, of course, is famously associated with words. If, if men were angels, no government would be necessary. And of course, we are not in, in terms of defining not being angels was.

23:06 Madison's analysis that we were rageful or economically self-interested in tend tending towards faction, or are those in his mind the same thing? Well, it may be in some ways the same thing. You know, I, people often will ask me, you know, it seems like Madison was a cynic, uh, that, you know, he talked about factions and how, uh, people form factions. I always push back on that. In some ways, I consider Madison the greatest of optimists because he. Took us for who we are. He didn't, you know, I always tell my students, when my students come up and say, oh, I read, I I've read the US Constitution. I just love it. It's so beautiful. I, I know they've never read the US Constitution 'cause they, well they probably used AI to read it.

23:48 They've probably got a summary. Yeah. US Constitution reads like the tax code. I mean it, there's nothing but I tell 'em, if you wanna read a beautiful constitution, read any of the French constitutions. I mean, 'cause they had a lot of practice 'cause they failed so often and. You know, but they knew how to write a constitution. They would talk about the rights of man, this horizonal view of who we are, and they would have a revolution, and the next morning they'd wake up and have that morning after feeling that you're not quite the, yeah. Jonathan, what's, you know, I've heard the, it's an interesting argument. I've heard it many times before. What's original about your argument about this distinction between the American and the French Revolution? Well, that's really not the thrust of the book. The thrust of the book.

24:28 Uh, is so you would acknowledge it's not particularly original. That, uh, about how often the French, about the, well, the, the American was Madisonian and the French was rooted in violence and rage and Rob Spear and the guillotine. No, the book, the book actually, uh, does, it does not just say that the book looks at. The French Revolution and the difference between Voltaire and, and and Rousseau. You know, it was famously said by one French, French historian that the first French revolution was Volta, and the second, which became the reign of terror, was Rousseau. And I look at, at what were the contributors there, because the thrust of my book is really to sort of have some.

25:11 Guide a survival guide, uh, for, uh, this republic in the 21st century. And we're going to have to rely on those elements more than we have ever done before. And the concern I raise is that many of my colleagues, a lot of law professors, law deans. Uh, our calling for removing some of the very elements, identifying the book is key to why we stabilized and became. So are you suggesting that there are robe spears hidden in lots of law departments around the country? Um, I'm not saying that, in fact, in the book I say I don't believe that any of these new jacobins want to see, uh, um, you know, the, uh, the carts rolled down Pennsylvania Avenue, but neither did robes Pierre.

25:57 Uh, when he began. The key is that you can lose control, uh, to a mob if you, if you have more direct democratic impulse, if you remove these precautions. And what concerns me is, you know, one of the priorities is the change the Supreme Court to pack the supreme. Uh, also to change the US Senate, uh, with the Dean of Berkeley Law School has a book out saying, no constitution lasts forever, and says that the US Constitution is now the threat that has to be overcome. Who's the dean of the Berkeley Law School? Uh, Irwin Chasky. Yeah. He is been on the show. Let's, so let's fast forward, let's get to the core of the book. Yesterday was the Super Bowl, uh, supposedly bringing Americans.

26:40 Together of course. Although if anything, it divided them even more attitudes to culture and politics. Some people might be listening to this, um, Jonathan, and thinking, well, this guy's talking about the dangers of mob ocracy, but he's on Fox News all the time. Isn't the danger of mob, ocracy and rage isn't that more manifest on the right with the followers of MAGA and Trump than it is on the left? In America in 2026. I don't see how you could argue that in the sense that there's rage on both sides. You see it all around you. Rage is a strange thing. It gives you license to say and do things you would not ordinarily say or do, but what people won't admit on either side.

27:26 Is that they like it, it's addictive and it's contagious. I, I don't see any difference in that sense. I, and although, uh, coming back to the politicians, I know, you know, you're not a big admirer of. Some of the, the politicians on the left, you wrote something critical of, of Newsom, but Trump seems to capture the, the sort of the rageful zeitgeist of the age more than anyone else, doesn't he? I certainly don't see a, a rageful trump on the left in America, or at least one who has any political skills. I'm not too sure how you could have missed that. Well, who would be an example? Well, you have everyone from Governor Waltz to the members of Congress calling ice Nazis, Gestapo, uh, saying there's gonna be Nuremberg trials.

28:17 What do you call that? If it's not, they say that, well, but what is not a, I wanna correct something out. And that is, I've been critical of both sides. My students will tell you I haven't liked the president since James Madison, and so I have criticized President Trump and when I thought he was right, I have said that as well. But there is no lock on rage today. That is a. Conceit that people love to say that it's the other side, right. My rage is righteous. Their rage is dangerous. That's very much the voice of rage. And are you raging against rage, though? It sounds, if you might be a bit, no, 'cause I actually, I don't think that it's, the rage itself is, is the threatening element.

29:01 We have a system that can handle rage. It, it was, I, I testified once in Congress when one of the members asked me, you know, you always talk to us about, uh, the framers, but you know, people today talk like they're trying to kill each other. And I pointed out, you know, congressman, they were actually trying to kill each other back then. The, the US Constitution wasn't just written for times like this. It was written during a time like this. It was designed to handle rage. I'm not afraid of the rage. What I'm afraid of is removing the elements that we need to regulate, uh, and moderate the rage. That's what can become a hypocrisy. Are we a hypocrisy now?

29:42 No, because we have a system designed not to let that happen. Go. Going back to pain, say comparing the comparison of pain, who was. An itinerant Englishman who suffered a lot in his life in Jefferson, who was an aristocrat and had a wonderful estate on Monticello, lots of slaves, even a slave wife. He had reason to be cheerful with his wine and his fancy new estate. Uh, some people might argue in America in 2026, Jonathan, that there's all reason to be raged too much more and more inequalities, more and more of a struggle to survive, to pay one's rent, anger on the street, anger against the police, anger within the police, blah, blah, blah.

30:25 Can one argue in 2026 that the. Rage that you fear and are critical of is almost logical, inevitable, given the economic and cultural organization of the current republic. I, the, that's actually what I say in the book, that the, I don't actually, I, I don't actually. Uh, condemn rage as an emotion or a passion. I, I believe rage is something inherent during times of great economic, uh, and political change. That's not the problem. Uh, but what I am warning about in the book is our, how we're going to face what's coming.

31:07 Which I believe with AI and robotics will I take the most conservative estimates on the loss of jobs from uh, from that technology. And we are looking at the possibility of a very large static unemployed. Class of individuals who would be supported by the state and the book asks, how does that change a citizen's relationship to the state? I disagree with you by the way, when you said that pain was not a big fan of capitalism. I think you're wrong. And uh, you know, I note in the book that, you know, the Wealth of Nations came out the year of our. Of the Declaration of Independence, it was embraced here. It was not a huge success in Europe.

31:48 It was a big success here. 'cause the founders viewed his economic theory as being the perfect companion to their political theory, and it was the combination of that. That helped stabilize the system. Payne actually said many things in agreement with, with Smith. He was also, however, very forward looking. He would talk about things that we would consider today to be public welfare systems, but he was actually a fairly, um, outspoken supporter of free markets. Yeah, and of course Smith himself was not really smithian in the sense that some.

32:28 Libertarians have interpreted it. So Jonathan, let's get to the heart of the book then. If indeed, America is on the brink of a new chapter of massive rage, if everyone's about to lose their jobs to ai. What would you advise is the solution? Political, economic, cultural. I actually think the, the book talks about a number of elements that we have to focus on. One is we can't have a kept population, so you can't, uh, this republic won't work if people are simply subsidized by the government. It won't work because it denies something very human about us, not just our relationship to the government, but people need to be productive. They need to have a way.

33:10 One of the things the framers liked about Smith was they believed that if you weren't economically independent, you'd never truly be free. So the book talks about mistakes that we have to avoid, subsidizing industries that are going to be devastated by AI and robotics. Uh, that's usually the first tendency of politicians is just prop up industries like that, or, or the coal industry in West Virginia that, yeah. Well the key is to find homo centric. Uh, um, occupations and I talk about those, uh, a shift, but we cannot have what I call an arts and crafts population. You can't just entertain the population, uh, that will have no productive use.

33:55 'cause human beings have to be productive in my field. So you are not a big fan of the abundance argument either. Um, Ezra Klein and Derek Thompson, or the more radical abundance argument out in Silicon Valley that technology will liberate us from labor. It's really Marx. His, uh, German. A German ideology argument that, uh, we'll all be free to be writers or philosophers or poets in the afternoon. You don't believe in any of that? I don't. And I go into in depth on that as to why it's important for people to be productive. You know, I talk about the fact that, look, one of my grandfathers was a coal miner who got black lung in the minds of Ohio.

34:35 The other one was a, was a Cooper. He made barrels. Neither of them liked their job. I mean, one almost killed my, my Italian grandfather, but if you asked him who he was. Even long after he had left the mines, he said he was a coal miner. And the reason is that we are often identified with what makes us productive. That's why people come to this country, to reinvent themselves, to find their own manifest destiny. The second chances. Yeah. And I think that this idea that we're just going to be a kept population, uh, ignores that very human need. So I, I take your point, Jonathan. I'm not sure anyone would necessarily argue, but in, in our age where we have a, a winner take all capitalism where we have fewer and fewer companies controlling more and more of the economy, uh, open AI anthropic will likely do their IPOs this year.

35:29 These new AI companies are controlling everything they'll eliminate for better or worse, willingly or, or consciously or otherwise. Jobs to, to borrow, uh, another phrase from a, another revolutionary, I'm sure one that you're not keen on Lenin. What is to be done, what, what should happen? What are you arguing in favor of? Well, I'm arguing in favor of preserving, trying to reduce the dependency and ation of the population by making wise choices as to how we support certain industries, but also to reaffirm those elements. That protect liberty. And many of those elements are the ones being under attack by many folks, including many law professors.

36:13 And so I, I try to argue as best I can, uh, that we need to preserve that more than ever. Uh, and that could be the key here because. I talk about what I call corporate feudalism, uh, which is the rise of these major corporations and the dangers they, they present Also, global governance systems like the eu, uh, which I believe is probably the worst positioned in dealing with the problems that are coming. I believe the eu. Could ultimately collapse in spectacular fashion because it does not have the elements that I discussed in this book that are going to be necessary to protect individual liberty. And what happens is that when you have a system like that collapse, it's very dangerous because it often ends up in tyranny.

37:01 Yeah, I take your point, although it's not, it's, it's not a book about the eu, but then if everything you're saying is true, and I don't think many people would disagree that people are gonna lose their jobs, their ways of life. You're arguing against state intervention. You're arguing that a kept population is a, is an unfree population, an un-American population. What becomes of the, the people who lose their jobs, if you're not gonna give them guaranteed minimum income, which I'm sure you're against, then what are they supposed to do? Are you falling back on a kind of hard victorianism? These people should just die on the street. I'm not too sure why you think I'm against supporting people who don't have jobs.

37:44 Of course, I'm in favor of that. But you're against the cap population. That's right. But there's, there's a little room between that and leaving a population to starve. I mean the, I think that we are going to have to subsidize a large population of unemployed. The question is, what will we do beyond the subsidization? And I argue against certain moves like the subsidy of failing industries and instead shifting over to industries that will remain homo centric. There are certain types of jobs that people are still gonna want a human. Element in the book. I actually call them GYN jobs. Um, and only nerds will understand that term.

38:24 Uh, 'cause GYN was the bartender on, uh, the um. Next generation on, on, uh, on the enterprise and 10 forward. And I always, so you're a Star Trek person too. You've got a little bit of Well, but it, I always admit was I, I always thought it was curious growing up that you had a replicator right behind Gyan that could make the perfect Rolin sunrise cocktail, and yet people would have her make it, even though that replicator could make literally the perfect cocktail. But this is all fantasy, Jonathan. It's all very well for professors like yourself too. No, hold on. People are gonna lose their jobs. Right. Over, over all this, you, you're not in favor of subsidizing coal miners or maybe lawyers because they're gonna be out of work through ai.

39:12 What are you suggesting? Everyone should become masses. I mean, gimme some examples of work that you think will flourish in this. Age of ai? Of robotics. Well, I was getting to that. The question is what are GY jobs? What are jobs that people still want a human being to do? And there's a great variety of them from education to certain areas of medicine. I talk about how certain areas of medicine are going to be largely wiped out by ai, robotics. Things like you're not gonna have as many radiologists, uh, just because it's sort of silly. If you can have AI do that function better, but you are gonna have psychiatrists, psychologists. Analyst. You're also gonna have a lot of, of industries, particularly like education, that people are going to still, which is one of the largest employers already in the United States.

39:58 There are more teachers, although AI can replace teachers, why, why shouldn't a, a smart machine replace a teacher and more than a, a smart machine? Replace a lawyer. Because I, I think it's possible they could, but I do think that that may be a GYN area that, uh, people are still going to want to have human beings involved, including with the law. For example, we've seen ai, uh, involved in the law in a very significant way, but I still think that there's going to be a desire to have human lawyers, human judges. So there's industries like that that we have to. To, to see. So the argument here is not, don't subsidize starving people. Obviously we are gonna be giving some type of living wage to a large population.

40:42 But what we have to look at is how that affects politically, the relationship of citizens to the government, and how we can preserve the sense of productivity, individuality, uh, that citizens need, uh, to feel fully human. What about the top villian analysis of revolution, Jonathan? That people get angriest, not when they're at their poorest or when they're suffering the most, but actually when they're a little better off is rage rational. Well, rage can't be rational. You know, it's also very subjective, right? That it's, uh, your rage is righteous.

41:23 Their rage is dangerous. Uh, you know, I've been a legal analyst for Ford Networks for 30 years. C-B-S-N-B. CBBC, uh, and Fox recently, and I've always seen rage on both sides. Uh, and there's always a reason for it. Uh, that's the thing about rage. It's what rage unleashes that can become dangerous if it's not controlled. And that's what Madison and others tried to do, um, did very well. I think. Um, it's what the French failed to do with their early constitutions. Uh, so we have to look at that.

42:06 And we also have to preserve what I call a liberty enhancing economy. That, you know, yes, we're gonna have to subsidize a large population of unemployed people and many of those individuals, because of their age, we have to accept, are probably not going to be employed again. But we have to be able to use these years to try to prepare for that. Uh, we just can't just cut them checks. Uh, we have to look at the implications politically and socially for people who. Are kept in that sense. So your solution isn't not so much legal, even if you're a legal analyst, it's economic and political. Are there models of this? I mean, are you really calling for a, a digital new deal?

42:48 Is FDR the model here? No, I wouldn't necessarily say that. I think that. Uh, what we do have to do is to try to preserve capitalistic elements to allow people to, so where's the model then? I I take your point. If you're not falling back on FDR, I'm not sure pain would be particularly helpful here, or even Madison or Jefferson. Where's the model in American history who? Who addressed this issue in a way that you think we can learn from? Or is it so new that we're gonna need to invent new political ideas and politicians? I'm not sure we'll need new political ideas as much as, uh, retooling the ideas we had at the beginning of the revolution.

43:29 We have a system that is designed to deal with these types of pressures, but we are going to have a mix of social programs, things like a living wage. Uh, we're gonna have to be nimble. Uh, it means that we're gonna have to accept that many industries are going to be robotic, uh, or changed by ai. Uh, we are going to have to try to encourage people to go into those more homo centric industries. I think education will be, I say encourage, I mean. What, what exactly does that mean? Are they being paid to do it? Are they being forced to do it? No, it's to the degree that the government favors new industries. It should be, in fact, new industries, not subsidizing, failing industries.

44:10 Uh, but also there's a lot of education that the government can help here and directing people who are, who want to be employed. Into areas where there is greater potential for that employment. What you don't want is to have this sort of past dependence where you have people training for jobs that simply won't be there. Right. They, excuse me. I mean, if you are, you know, training to be a radiologist today, I'm afraid that's a bit of a mistake. Uh, and you have to, well, their government never really knows. I mean, who knows whether. Radiologists or lawyers or engineers or politicians or law professors, uh, it sounds to me, Jonathan f finally, that your ideal state, I know you're not a big fan of the eu, but there is a kind of technocratic, enlightenment, fantasy that you have of government may not be quite the eu, but it's Danish or German smart state trying to push people into.

45:08 Industries that are relevant for the future rather than the past, certainly. Not a MAGA person. You're not a, a Nostalgist, but is there a, a kind of government, maybe the, the Chinese or the Korean or the Danish that, that, that suits your, your vision of the future? Who gets who's getting it right? I actually think the American Republic actually offers the best structure here. And, um, I don't think it's just the government's job. When I talk about educating people, it's going to be a job of society. It's gonna be our trying to direct these discussions, uh, into areas where people can be productive, can be self-expressive.

45:49 The EU is not the model. In fact, the book goes into how all rights like politics are local. And we have to support, uh, the sort of decentralization of politics. It's the centralization of power that I'm worried about in, in groups like the eu because I think that the EU is inherently unstable. Well, there you have it. Excellent. Uh, conversation by, uh, gw, professor of Law in new book, rage in the Republic, the unfinished story of the American Revolution. One thing for sure. It is indeed an unfinished story. Uh, Jonathan, uh, Turley, congratulations on the new book, and thank you for a fascinating conversation. Well, thank you.

46:29 I enjoyed it a great deal. Thanks for having me on.