Nov. 11, 2026

John Doe Chinaman: Beth Lew-Williams on the History of Chinese Life under American Racial Law

John Doe Chinaman: Beth Lew-Williams on the History of Chinese Life under American Racial Law
Keen On America
John Doe Chinaman: Beth Lew-Williams on the History of Chinese Life under American Racial Law

“The systematic erasure of the Chinese was not an accident. It was, in many ways, structured.” — Beth Lew-Williams

Her Chinese-American grandfather asked her to turn off the tape recorder as they spoke. Beth Lew-Williams was a history student interviewing her grandad, her YeYe, two weeks before he died. He had come to America in 1930, aged nine, in violation of the Chinese Exclusion Acts, and was held on Angel Island for what he always said was nine months. Years later she looked up the file. It was “only” thirty-four days.

It was the shame of it all, he confessed to Lew-Williams, after she switched off the recorder. For his whole life, he blamed himself rather than American racial laws for his humiliation.

That student is now a professor of history at Princeton, and this year she has won more or less every prize for John Doe Chinaman, her history of Chinese life under American racial law. The Bancroft. The American Book Award. The Merle Curti for social history. The Langum for legal history. The Western History Association’s book prize. And now the grand Canadian one, the 2026 Cundill, worth seventy-five thousand dollars, the most lucrative history prize in the world.

“John Doe Chinaman” is the term Lew-Williams kept meeting in the archives — in the court records, in the census, in the newspapers. Record after record of that nameless Chinese man. Such anonymity, she argues, was purposefully manufactured by thousands of local and state laws governing where Chinese people could live, who they could marry, and whether they could testify against a white man in court.

A Chinese Jim Crow? Lew-Williams reminds us that the earliest racial zoning laws in America were aimed at the Chinese. So were the earliest restrictive covenants, written into deeds in the 1880s. First Chinese-Americans. Then African-Americans. The subtitle of John Doe Chinaman describes it as a “forgotten” history. No longer. This acclaimed book forces us to remember the humiliation of nameless Chinese immigrants like Lew-Williams’s YeYe.


FURTHER READING

• John Doe Chinaman: A Forgotten History of Chinese Life under American Racial Law (Harvard University Press), by Beth Lew-Williams.

• The Chinese Must Go: Violence, Exclusion, and the Making of the Alien in America (Harvard University Press), by Beth Lew-Williams.

• The 2026 shortlist, Cundill History Prize.

• The 2026 Bancroft Prizes, Columbia University Libraries.

• Beth Lew-Williams, Department of History, Princeton University.

• KEEN ON AMERICA episodes cited: Sophia Rosenfeld on the age of choice, Joseph Kelly on the prehistory of American fascism, Stacey Patton on how white America learned to lynch black children, and Susan Neiman on calling it evil.


ABOUT THE GUEST

Beth Lew-Williams is a professor of history at Princeton, where in 2014 she became the university’s first appointment in Asian American history. She grew up in Davis, California and took her doctorate at Stanford. Her first book, The Chinese Must Go: Violence, Exclusion, and the Making of the Alien in America, won two book prizes from the Organization of American Historians. John Doe Chinaman: A Forgotten History of Chinese Life under American Racial Law is published by Harvard University Press and won the 2026 Cundill History Prize, along with the Bancroft Prize, the American Book Award, the Merle Curti Social History Award, the David J. Langum Sr. Prize in American Legal History and the Western History Association’s book prize.


ABOUT KEEN ON AMERICA

Nobody asks more awkward questions than the Anglo-American writer and filmmaker Andrew Keen. With 3,000 episodes since the show launched on TechCrunch in 2010, Keen On America is a daily conversation about the ideas, books and arguments shaping the United States. New episodes every day.

00:00 - Intro

00:31 - AK: last year the shortlist, this year the winner

01:30 - AK: tell me about the genealogy of the book

01:36 - Eight years, and a move from the border to the everyday

02:46 - AK: what was unique about the Chinese experience?

03:09 - The 1790 law, and racial ineligibility for citizenship

03:50 - Permanent outsiders: where nativism and racism fuse

04:27 - AK: how does the violence compare with anti-black violence?

05:16 - Why she resists the comparison

05:40 - Arriving in the 1850s, at the very end of slavery

06:13 - AK: you have been very polite about my vulgar question

06:19 - Why we reach for the comparison in the first place

06:40 - 165 communities try to expel their Chinese neighbors, 1885–86

07:10 - Expulsion in the West, keeping people in place in the South

07:58 - AK: the Bancroft, the Curti, the Langum, the Cundill — enough

09:16 - Her own family, and coal miners in Wyoming

09:50 - Her YeYe, and an oral history two weeks before he died

10:30 - Thirty-four days on Angel Island, remembered as nine months

11:15 - He asked her to turn off the tape recorder

11:40 - Telling the history that would have explained his shame

12:10 - AK: how much does culture matter here?

12:58 - The accusation of clannishness

13:48 - AK: the same charge was made against everyone else

13:53 - Chinatown as a product of segregation, not preference

14:32 - AK: did China’s own humiliation carry over?

15:23 - Geopolitics and race relations

16:00 - Chinese diplomatic protests that fall on deaf ears

16:30 - Japan complains about segregated schoolchildren, and America listens

17:08 - AK: what was the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882?

17:24 - The first federal law to bar a group by race and class

18:00 - Having to invent border control, and the rights of aliens

18:33 - AK: so who was actually behind it?

19:06 - Democrats, the West Coast and labor against capital

19:40 - Republicans, the China trade and the Protestant missionaries

20:10 - The exceptions carved out for merchants, diplomats and students

20:43 - AK: did eugenics play a part in this?

21:01 - Heathen coolies: the stereotype behind the statutes

22:11 - AK: were the labor unions part of it?

22:24 - Ten per cent of California, twenty per cent of the workforce

22:44 - AK: what number are we actually talking about?

22:47 - Fifty thousand, and almost entirely male

23:10 - The union they might have joined, and the unions that barred them

23:35 - AK: was there any truth to the strikebreaking charge?

23:38 - Rock Springs, Wyoming, and the price per ton of coal

24:16 - AK: why John Doe Chinaman and not Heathen Coolies?

24:32 - A term from the court records, the census and the newspapers

25:20 - The cover typescript comes from an actual court case

25:50 - Erasure that was structured rather than accidental

26:24 - AK: how do these laws compare with Jim Crow?

26:41 - School segregation and anti-miscegenation, in both directions

27:30 - Copycat laws: barring Chinese testimony against white parties

28:00 - The earliest racial zoning laws were aimed at the Chinese

28:40 - Restrictive covenants begin in the 1880s, against the Chinese

29:30 - AK: is there an equivalent in the female experience?

30:05 - Chinese women as five per cent of the population

30:28 - Trafficking, prostitution, and transpacific families

31:00 - Archival absence, and who leaves no written record

31:29 - AK: is the point of these histories to shame America?

32:15 - She did not write it to shame anyone

32:50 - Beyond the Transcontinental Railroad: a long history, and a hard one

33:24 - AK: will readers make moral judgments?

33:50 - What she wants people to think about is power

34:32 - AK: what does the book tell us about immigration now?

35:22 - Unable to naturalize from 1790 until 1943

36:30 - AK: is it ironic that China is now a rival superpower?

37:12 - Not a new moment so much as a return

38:00 - Alien land laws, then and now

38:53 - Closing

00:00:31 Andrew Keen: Hello, everybody. Last year, we did a show with the very talented young historian, American historian, Sophia Rosenfeld, who had a book out last year called The Age of Choice: A History of Freedom in Modern Life, that was shortlisted for the very distinguished Canadian prize, the Cundill Prize. And we're going one better this year. We're back with Cundill Prize finalists. But this time, we're talking to the winner of the 2026 Cundill Prize, Beth Lew-Williams, whose new book, John Doe Chinaman: A Forgotten History of Chinese Life under American Racial Law, has just been given the award. Beth is joining us from Princeton, New Jersey where she teaches. Beth, congratulations on the award and on the book.


00:01:28 Beth Lew-Williams: Thank you.


00:01:30 Andrew Keen: Did it take a lot of time? Tell me more about the genealogy of the book.


00:01:36 Beth Lew-Williams: I worked on this book for about eight years. You know, it took a while. You know, the book, it came out of my previous books— my previous book, which is called The Chinese Must Go, looked at the role of racial violence in the making of, Chinese exclusion and immigration control in the United States more broadly. And so that book really had me focused on the border, and how Chinese immigrants' lives were affected by federal attempts to keep them out, to exclude them from America. But one of the things that struck me when I was writing that book was that I was really focusing on the exceptional moment. Right? The exceptional moment in someone's life when they're crossing a border and an exceptional level of violence that, Chinese immigration, you know, inspired. And so with this book, I wanted to turn to the everyday and try to really understand what Chinese people's lives were like in nineteenth- and early twentieth-century America, and not just at those exceptional moments.


00:02:46 Andrew Keen: I don't wanna turn this kind of conversation into a kind of a relative comparison of suffering, but, of course, it wasn't only people from China who suffered in nineteenth-century America. What was unique, about the experience of people from China in nineteenth-century America, and what was different?


00:03:09 Beth Lew-Williams: Yeah. It— It's a— It's good to point out that, you know, a lot of people were marginalized in America. It was a very hierarchical society in the nineteenth century. I think, you know, a few things stand out for the Chinese. I mean, the Chinese— I think one of the central things is that they were racially barred from naturalization. It was— It's actually a 1790 law that made it so only, free white people could naturalize. And, given just the folks that were coming over at the time, Chinese immigrants were sort of the first group to encounter that law and that exclusion because most immigrants were coming from Europe. And I think that really set them on a different course. Right? They were considered racially nonwhite, incapable of becoming US citizens, and that meant that they didn't have the same routes towards integration into America. And it meant that they were seen as a permanent form of outsiders in American society. So while other groups face nativism, and other groups faced racism, I think the Chinese case gives us a sense of how those two things could intertwine for a particular, you know, immigrant group.


00:04:27 Andrew Keen: And the obvious comparison, of course, is with African Americans. We've done many shows. It is the first show I think we've done on the Chinese experience in nineteenth-century America. We did one recently with Joe Kelly, The Biggest Lie: The Prehistory of American Fascism, and then one recently with another very talented writer, Stacey Patton, who has a new book out about how white America learned to lynch black children, a very controversial book as you can imagine. How much violence, Beth, was associated with the treatment of, Chinese people in nineteenth-century America? Does it compare with the kind of violence that was unleashed on black Americans both before and after the end of slavery?


00:05:16 Beth Lew-Williams: Yeah. I try not to fall into, you know, basic comparisons between these two groups because the histories are so different. I mean, part of the difference is that they're, they're in different parts of the country, and they're arriving at different times. Right? So the Chinese only arrive in large numbers starting in the 1850s. So they really arrive at the very sort of end of the history of slavery in the United States. Most— You know, by the time they're in large numbers, maybe 60,000 of them by 1870, emancipation has happened. And they enter California where they're— They are the largest nonwhite community by 1870. They outnumber black people by, you know, 10 times. And so there— It's hard to compare because, you know, there's certain kinds of violence on the West and certain kinds of violence in the South. But I'll give you a little bit of a comparison.


00:06:13 Andrew Keen: Yeah. You've been very polite to my rather, rather vulgar question. I apologize.


00:06:19 Beth Lew-Williams: No. It's okay. I, you know, I think that part of the reason that we have this impulse to compare, I think, is because there's, you know, most people get much less education on, Asian American history than they do black, history in the United States. And so as we're trying to understand the Chinese, you know, often they get slotted into, like, oh, is this like a store— Like the story of African Americans in the United States? I mean, so I'll give you an example. Maybe that's helpful. You know, in my first book, I talk about anti-Chinese violence, but I think that the violence, the sort of violence I'm talking about is really different than we see, against black people at the same time period. So I focus in the 1880s. And most of the violence, you know, there's this unprecedented wave in 1885 and 1886 where, more than 165 communities across the American West attempt to expel their Chinese neighbors. And they do so through, you know, outright assault, arson, or simply just rounding up people or intimidation, boycott, things like that. But I think this is really interesting because at the same time, late nineteenth century, in the South, we see anti-black violence, but that anti-black violence is very much about keeping people in place. Right? Their need— Black labor is needed in the South, and they're kept in place sort of, you know, physically, economically, and politically through, you know, this history of lynching, for example. It's a very different kind of violence, and the aim is very different as well.


00:07:58 Andrew Keen: Yeah. And just to remind everyone, your first book was called The Chinese Must Go, another very interesting book. I guess it didn't win as many prizes, but we can't win all the prizes. This year, you won, I think, every single prize for history. You won the Bancroft Prize, the Merle Curti Social History Award, the American Book Award, the David J. Langum Sr. Prize in American Legal History, the Cundill History Prize, and the Western History Association prize. Enough embarrassing you. Yeah. But, coming back to this issue of the West and the Chinese versus the southern experience and African Americans, I know you grew up in California, just up the road from me, in Davis, and then you went to graduate school at Stanford, in Palo Alto. So you're a Californian at least— even though now you're living and teaching in Princeton, New Jersey. What does this— Is that why you've dedicated at least a lot of your life to studying the experience of Chinese people in America? Why did you go that way as opposed to so many other alternatives for historians, especially of American immigration?


00:09:16 Beth Lew-Williams: Yeah. I mean, I think it goes back to my own family's history. You know, I'm multiracial and, you know, there's different immigration histories in my background, but one of them is Chinese. So my Chinese relatives, came to the United States in the nineteenth century. They were coal miners in Wyoming. And I think growing up, in the public schools in California, I just really didn't learn much about the Chinese American experience, and I didn't learn enough to understand the stories that I was being told. You know, if I can— I often talk about one moment that maybe set me on the path to becoming a historian and particularly a historian of Chinese in America. And that was, when I was in college, I went to see my grandfather, my YeYe. And, I was sent there by an Asian American history class that, asked us to do an oral history of some— Of somebody with pertinent experience. I went to see my grandfather, and it turned out to be two weeks before he passed away. And I was interviewing him because he had, you know, a story very much linked to what we're talking about. He came to the United States in 1930 when, Chinese were banned from coming during the Chinese exclusion era. He came in violation of the law, and he came as a nine year old. And so he was detained on Angel Island Immigration Station just off the Bay of San Francisco. For— You know, at the time, he told me it was nine months or maybe a year. You know, years later, I looked up his immigration records and found that it was, just thirty four days that he was detained. But you can get a sense even from that discrepancy, you know, how large—


00:11:11 Andrew Keen: I mean, I'm sure it was such a miserable experience. He's allowed to exaggerate a little bit.


00:11:15 Beth Lew-Williams: Yes. And, well, and he was nine years old. You can see how large it must have loomed, you know, in his life and in his memory. But, anyhow, that's— That, conversation really, stayed with me in part because he asked me to turn off the tape recorder before he talked about his shame about arriving in violation of the Chinese Exclusion Acts. And, you know, only told that part of the story, not on tape and not for my paper. And I think that it was, you know, he held that, shame as a personal burden as his own, you know, his own misdeed. And I think that in many ways, my work is about trying to tell the history that he didn't know that would have helped him to understand the structures, that he was caught within.


00:12:10 Andrew Keen: There are all sorts of political minefields here, Beth, but I'm still gonna ask this question, and you can tell me if it's, again, another inappropriate one. How much does culture matter here? I mean, we're, of course, told, and I know you're a professor of history at Princeton, so I know you know this better than I do, that cultural groups don't necessarily all think alike and that they have— That it's very dangerous to make generalizations. But given that particular anecdote about the shame of your Chinese grandfather, can one make generalizations about the Chinese experience in nineteenth-century America that is different from other groups?


00:12:58 Beth Lew-Williams: You know, I— You made me a little antsy there talking about cultural difference because I think that, you know, as a historian, I— That's not the way that I usually think. I'm usually thinking, you know, in more specific terms. Yes. There are some, you know, cultural distinctions, knowledge, and beliefs that people arrived with when they came to America, and we can, to some extent, see the effects of that. But we also see the effects of their reception. I mean— So for example, I think that, at the time, the nineteenth century, Chinese were often accused of being clannish, you know, that they didn't, consort with non-Chinese people, that they lived altogether, that they were uninterested in becoming American.


00:13:48 Andrew Keen: But it looks not very different from the accusation against many other groups, of course.


00:13:53 Beth Lew-Williams: Yeah. It's not that different. But, you know, I think if we look back, we can see the wider picture that, you know, there were all of these ways in which Chinese were not, permitted to assimilate. And we can see that clannishness, that idea of a Chinatown, was often caused by segregation as opposed to choice by Chinese immigrants. So I, you know, I resist, ideas of culture that sort of carry across time or, label a group sort of broadly.


00:14:32 Andrew Keen: Let me revise the question then again, and I'm probably gonna get myself into more trouble here. But, given the history of nineteenth-century China— Or, again, I'm making massive generalizations about stuff that I'm not particularly familiar with but, again, correct me if I'm wrong. And given the humiliation of much of the nineteenth century for many people of living in China or what we call China, did that carry over given the success of the West, given the European colonial project, given the role of America and all that? Did that carry over in some way or other in the Chinese experience in the United States?


00:15:23 Beth Lew-Williams: I mean, we definitely see the relationship between geopolitics, right, and race relations in the United States. That's sort of a general, observation. So for China at the time, you know, China in the nineteenth century was dominated by western powers. It was, you know, subject to western imperialism. It was definitely, you know, a nation in decline at this time. And I think that there were ramifications for Chinese immigrants in America. Some of them, you know, maybe in this broad terms that Chinese were regarded as inferior to Americans, not just on racial terms, but on that, like, their nationhood on the— On terms of nationality. But I also think in very tangible ways, right, that the Chinese government tried to advocate on behalf of overseas Chinese in the United States. They protested things, that I write about some of the racial laws that the Chinese encountered. They protest against violence against the Chinese. But their protests often, you know, fall on deaf ears because the United States is not particularly concerned about what, China thinks. And we can see the effects of this if we compare it, for example, to complaints by the Japanese, by Japan, by the Japanese empire in early twentieth century when they complained to the United States about, you know, segregation of Japanese schoolchildren in San Francisco, for example. The United States listened to that. Right? Because they were aware that, Japan was a more powerful, and growing empire.


00:17:08 Andrew Keen: Remind us, I'm gonna ask a very noncontroversial question, a good solid historical one, Beth, so I don't get into any more trouble. What was the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882, and why is it so important?


00:17:24 Beth Lew-Williams: It's— The Chinese Exclusion Act, so there's a bunch of them, are so important because they're the first example of a federal law that, barred people based on race and class and affected, you know, a large cohort of immigrants. And this— You know, in many ways, the Chinese Exclusion Acts are, you know, some of the first federal immigration laws to bar any group. And it means that not only, you know, are the— It's just the first laws. It's also that the United States then has to build border control, the structure of border control. How is it that you're going to prevent people from coming into the United States? And then they also have to determine at the Supreme Court that they have to determine lots of things about the legal rights of noncitizens, of aliens. Like, what rights do they have to contest their expulsion or their exclusion? And so it has a large amount of influence on, US border control going forward and the treatment of immigrants all the way to this day.


00:18:33 Andrew Keen: And who is behind it? I mean, when it comes to policymaking in the United States, certainly, that associated with racial matters. We all know the history of the South and Jim Crow, and all the debates around that. But who was behind these, acts designed to discriminate against Chinese immigrants? Were there racial groups in particular, or was it a socioeconomic or political phenomenon?


00:19:06 Beth Lew-Williams: You know, that we can draw some general, some general groups. You know? So the anti-Chinese, we sort of say it crudely, were particularly folks from the West Coast, where the Chinese were coming, Democrats at the time, and, those who supported white working class. Right? So those who were sort of on the side of labor as opposed to capital. On the other side, the pro-Chinese, because there were some, there were a lot of folks that were more, friendly and interested in Chinese immigration, and those folks tended to be more often than not Republican, sort of capitalists, businessmen, people invested in the China trade, and then often missionaries, protestant missionaries who were interested in converting Chinese immigrants and perhaps, even bringing, Christianity to China were also more friendly to Chinese immigration. So this really caused, a conflict in the United States. But, but this— You know, the ultimate sort of turn was towards exclusion for most Chinese immigrants. The Chinese Exclusion Act did have some exceptions and made exceptions for the elites. Right? It allowed Chinese merchants to continue to come, Chinese diplomats, and Chinese students. And you can see in that a bit of the compromise going on between, you know, these pro- and anti-Chinese forces.


00:20:43 Andrew Keen: We've done lots of shows on eugenics and the eugenicist movement in [unclear] twentieth-century America. Did this play a role? Were there people who believed that somehow people of Chinese descent were intellectually or physically inferior?


00:21:01 Beth Lew-Williams: Oh, yes. Certainly. I mean, there were, you know, there were racial scientific theories at the time, that the Chinese were distinct— You know, racially distinct and innately, inferior. You know, when I talk about this with my students, I'd say it usually boiled down to one per— You know, a sort of one particular stereotype that the Chinese were seen as, heathen coolies. That was the terminology at the time. And the heathen part, you know, obviously was religious, that they were non-Christian, but also it was, it was racial. There was an idea that they could not— They were innately different and could not change, could not assimilate. And then the coolie part was the idea that the Chinese were naturally servile, that they were naturally cheap labor and therefore would outcompete white workers. And so this— It was this particular kind of racial stereotype that was lobbed against the Chinese and really inspired a lot of the local and state laws that I talk about in John Doe Chinaman.


00:22:11 Andrew Keen: So labor unions or working class groups might have been in some ways, part of this given how they would have perceived it as undermining the value of their own labor?


00:22:24 Beth Lew-Williams: Oh, yes. Certainly. There were, a lot of labor unions. It's interesting. Right? Because the Chinese, made up a large percentage of the laboring class on the West Coast. So in California in 1870, they're 10% of the California population and 20% of the workforce.


00:22:44 Andrew Keen: What number would that have been? 10% of the population of California back then?


00:22:47 Beth Lew-Williams: I think that they're, they're about 50— A little over 50,000 Chinese in California in 1870. They're that larger proportion of the workforce because they are almost entirely male. So they're a large proportion of the workforce. And it's interesting, you know, because in another world, we could imagine that, that they could have been welcomed into unions and been part of the working class that was fighting for fair wages and, a good living standard. But instead, they are barred from almost every single union. And so, yes, they're seen as, you know, strikebreakers and those who might outcompete white workers.


00:23:35 Andrew Keen: Was there any truth to that?


00:23:38 Beth Lew-Williams: That they were strikebreakers? Yes. Sometimes they were brought in as strikebreakers. I mean, an example is, in Rock Springs, Wyoming. There were, you know, fights over the coal mines in Rock Springs, in a place where there were coal miners who were white and coal miners who were Chinese. And the Chinese were brought in large numbers into these coal mines in order to try to keep down the wages or the price per ton of coal that miners were allowed to take.


00:24:16 Andrew Keen: You introduced the phrase heathen coolies, which I guess could have been the title of the book. You chose, John Doe Chinaman. Why? What does John Doe Chinaman mean? Why did you choose this as the title of the book?


00:24:32 Beth Lew-Williams: Yeah. It's a historical term. It's a term that I ran into over and over again when I was looking at archival records, and I found it, you know, in court records, which was a lot of my source base. I found it in the census. John Chinaman, put in repeatedly. And I saw it in newspapers, and just everywhere. And it really struck me as this incredibly powerful term because it captures the way in which Chinese were seen as anonymous and as sort of all the same. Right? Not as individuals, but as these nameless, othered people. And, you know, and on the cover of my book, actually, the typescript of John Doe Chinaman is from a court case. Like, that's— That is the script, the nineteenth-century script of John Doe Chinaman. And I think, you know, what I was trying to do in this book was to expose the ways that Chinese had been sort of forcibly rendered anonymous in the American archive and in much of our American memory, and then to insist that they don't need to be anonymous, that we can dive into these nineteenth-century records and find some real names and tell some real stories about, Chinese. And then I also wanted to show, you know, that sort of systematic erasure of the Chinese was not an accident. It was not based on just, general racism or nativism. It was, in many ways structured. And so the book really looks at thousands of racial laws that regulated the everyday life of Chinese people at the local level and the state level on— In the American West.


00:26:24 Andrew Keen: How does it compare— And I know probably getting into trouble again because I'm doing another one of these comparisons. How does it then compare all these local state laws with Jim Crow? Like, the— There's series of laws that came out of the failure of Reconstruction after the Civil War.


00:26:41 Beth Lew-Williams: Yeah. I think that these laws are related to Jim Crow. So Jim Crow laws, they're, usually dated sort of 1880s and onward, in the South in particular, many of them around things like segregation. And we see examples of anti-Chinese laws that look really similar. So for example, you know, there are school segregation laws that affect black people. There's also school segregation laws, in California against Chinese. You see the same thing, anti-miscegenation laws, laws against interracial marriage affecting both Chinese and, black people. So there's definitely an overlap in what I'm talking about and Jim Crow. But one of the things I was interested in was, you know, the relationship between these two things. Right? Does, do anti-black laws inspire anti-Chinese laws or vice versa? And what— One of the interesting things that I found was that it really flowed both directions. Right? So there are some laws in, American West that are clearly copycats of anti-black laws that predate them. And, an example of this is laws against witness testimony in court. So Chinese people were barred from testifying against white parties in court in California, and this clearly comes from anti-black, and anti-native testimony laws that came earlier. But one of the things that I thought was really interesting was I also found, you know, inspiration going the other direction. So for example, the earliest known racial zoning laws, sort of saying where in a town or city, a population is allowed to live or not live. The earliest known racial zoning laws, are against the Chinese in the nineteenth century, and we don't see racial zoning laws affecting black people until the twentieth century. Another example of this is the— Is a legal technology called racial restrictive covenants. This is the practice of people writing into their property deeds or their leases that, that no Chinese people may live in this house or this apartment, racial restrictive covenants that become so central to residential segregation for black people in the twentieth century. The earliest known instances of them are for the Chinese, in the 1880s. And they don't really come, go east and affect black people again until the early twentieth century. And so I think it's really interesting to talk about maybe not the, you know, bold comparison between the two, but really the connections between the two.


00:29:30 Andrew Keen: Yeah. And thinking of your title, John Doe Chinaman, it brings to mind Sophia Rosenfeld. I'm not sure if you've seen her book, The Age of Choice: A History of Freedom in Modern Life, about women and their right to choose [ed.: Rosenfeld's book is a general history of choice as a form of freedom, not specifically about women]. I wonder, in a sense, in the way you're presenting the Chinese experience in nineteenth-century America as anonymous people forgotten as the John Doe Chinaman, whether there are equivalents also in the female experience in nineteenth-century America.


00:30:05 Beth Lew-Williams: I mean, well, I can certainly say that for Chinese women, you know, it's even more anonymous. Yeah.


00:30:10 Andrew Keen: I mean, double, double jeopardy.


00:30:14 Beth Lew-Williams: Yes. Well, there's so few of them. You know? For much of the late nineteenth century, they make up about 5% of the Chinese population.


00:30:24 Andrew Keen: They must have been rather popular, at least with the Chinese men.


00:30:28 Beth Lew-Williams: Yeah. Well, I mean, unfortunately, it caused a lot of, you know, trafficking and prostitution. So that was not good. But, yes, there were very few Chinese women. For the Chinese men, actually, just— We're going on a tangent here. A lot of them had families in China, and so they were really living transpacific lives. So they would work in the United States for a while and then travel home, to a wife and then come back again and bring family in that way. But, yes, you know, much— You know, historians face, the challenge of, you know, archival absences for many groups, and women is certainly one of them. You know, they just leave behind fewer written records, and especially since, you know, the Chinese women in the United States, the vast majority were not literate, and really not in public life. We just have very little about them.


00:31:29 Andrew Keen: I mentioned earlier that we had Stacey Patton on the show. Her book Strung Up: How White America Learned to Lynch Black Children. It's already a best seller, obviously, very controversial as you can guess from the title. And one of the things that we discussed was the whole point of these histories of shaming Americans. What's your take? Was there— Was that one reason? I mean, you're a more, I think, mainstream historian than Patton whose book is more designed, I think, for the trade press. But was one of the reasons you wrote this book and you've dedicated your professional life to writing about the experience of Chinese people in America, a way of reminding America of its sins?


00:32:15 Beth Lew-Williams: I mean, I certainly didn't write it to shame anyone. I don't— I don't think of it that way at all. I think that— I think that it's, you know, it's striking to me that we don't remember. Right? That, like, general public American memory, there's not much of a place for Chinese immigrants at all. You know, if you know a little bit, you know, usually, people know the Chinese helped to build the Transcontinental Railroad. Right? But that's sometimes the extent. And so, I mean, what— I— Really, I think what I want is for people to remember their existence and their long history in the United States. Right? Not just the late twentieth-century history, but people have history way back into the nineteenth century, their long history. And then the reality is if we're going to look at that, history, it's a very hard history. It's a history of racism and nativism and structural inequality. And so remembering does mean we have to remember difficult histories, but it's— That is not the main purpose of what I'm up to.


00:33:24 Andrew Keen: Will people make moral judgments after this book? We did a show with the moral philosopher, Susan Neiman recently, Call It Evil, a book about the Trump age and the MAGA age. Is the book designed to make people think about if not evil, certainly, immorality?


00:33:50 Beth Lew-Williams: I think, what I want people to think about, I want them to think about power. Right? The inequality and unequal amounts of power that we have, the ways in which the US government and laws and structures and court rulings, you know, accentuate the difference in power. And then the fact that people that are in power, if they, you know, hoard resources and scapegoat outsiders, that can, you know, further, marginalize, you know, groups like Chinese immigrants.


00:34:32 Andrew Keen: Finally, fast forwarding and, as you know as well as I do how controversial the issue of immigration is in the United States, both on the left and the right. And sometimes both people on the left and the right agree, on immigration, certainly in controlling it. What does this book tell us about, America's attitude to immigration? I mean, one maybe rather vulgar generalization is that every wave of immigrants, whether it's the Chinese or the Irish or the Italians or people from Latin America, they all experience the same thing, and then they become integrated. Is there any truth to that, to the Chinese experience?


00:35:22 Beth Lew-Williams: I mean, I think that, yes, there's— There is patterns of nativism or xenophobia against each new wave of immigrants. I think, again, that the history of Chinese is particular because of their inability to naturalize during this time period. Right? They were unable to naturalize between 1790 and 1943. That is a very long time that they were not welcomed as part of the American citizenry.


00:35:49 Andrew Keen: Not allowed to naturalize, it was a racial law suggesting that they couldn't become American citizens.


00:35:53 Beth Lew-Williams: They could not become American citizens. Immigrants could not become American citizens. So they're kept in this permanent, alien status, kept outside of the polity, unable to vote. So that is really distinct, I think, from other immigrant groups. Although, you know, after the Chinese, other Asian groups also suffer the same, the same fate from the same law. And, so, yes, eventually, there is further integration of the Chinese into the United States, but not during this time period that I'm writing about.


00:36:30 Andrew Keen: And is there, finally, finally, Beth, a kind of irony now in 2026 that, China, which had been used by the Western powers, if not formally colonized, certainly much weaker, kicked about by the West in the nineteenth and much of the twentieth century. Now it's emerging as a rival superpower to the United States. Is that ironic? And how does that, if anything, change the conversation about whether or not, the conversation about immigration and the relations between not just China and the United States, but people who come from China to the United States?


00:37:12 Beth Lew-Williams: You know, I think it's— I'm not sure if I would call it ironic. And I'm not sure, you know, just how surprising it is because the— You know, China was a very, you know, powerful country, you know, when America was founded. Right? You know, the, China had a population— Oh god. I'm gonna get this wrong. I think it was, like, 40 times the size of the United States when the United States was founded [ed.: closer to 75 times — roughly 300 million against the 3.9 million of the 1790 census]. You know, it, had a history that went back, you know, centuries at a time when the United States was just, you know, weeks old. And so the dominance of China in the world, I feel like in some ways, we're returning as opposed to, you know, entering a new moment. What's the effect? Well, you know, I think this is a very different time, but we are again seeing fears of Chinese immigrants, perhaps different sorts of fears, tied this time to the geopolitical strength of China. But it— Those fears can still affect, again, race relations and racial laws in the United States. And so a recent example has been the number of bills and laws introduced at the state level to try to dissuade, Chinese nationals from buying property in the United States. You know, alien land laws, you know, date back to the period that I'm writing about, and it's interesting to see, similar laws being brought about today again against Chinese immigrants.


00:38:53 Andrew Keen: Yeah. The paranoia associated with technology and AI is in some ways showing that history is repeating itself. Well, lovely to talk to you, Beth. You've carried off all the history prizes, for this year. John Doe Chinaman: A Forgotten History of Chinese Life under American Racial Law, has won the Cundill Prize, the Canadian prize. We should also remind people that there were runners-up: a very interesting book about Kim Il Sung and another one, The First Ghetto: Venice and the Jews. They were also distinguished runners-up. But, Beth, you carried away the prize, so congratulations. And lovely to talk to you. I have— I, I hope, I haven't humiliated myself with the vulgar questions.


00:39:42 Beth Lew-Williams: Thank you. Not at all. Thanks for having me.